Holy Ghost/Burning in the bosom
From FAIRMormon
FAIR: Defending The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints since 1997
| FAIRwiki portal |
| Holy Ghost |
|
| FAIRwiki articles |
|---|
| FAIR Wiki Topical Guide |
| FAIR web site |
| FARMS web site |
|
| Additional reading |
| Other portals |
Contents |
Criticism
- Critics complain that the LDS appeal to "revelation" or a "burning in the bosom" is subjective, emotion-based, and thus unreliable and susceptible to self-deception.
- Sectarian critics also belittle appeals to spiritual experiences, comparing them to "warm fuzzies," or merely something "felt by simply watching a Hollywood movie."
See also: Source(s) of the criticism
Response
And they said one to another, Did not our heart burn within us, while he talked with us by the way, and while he opened to us the scriptures?
—Luke 24:32
My heart was hot within me, while I was musing the fire burned: then spake I with my tongue.
—Psalms 39:3
But, behold, I say unto you, that you must study it out in your mind; then you must ask me if it be right, and if it is right I will cause that your bosom shall burn within you; therefore, you shall feel that it is right.
—D&C 9:8
Sectarian critics inconsistent
It is strange that sectarian critics fault appeals to a "burning in the bosom."
Following Jesus' resurrection, He walked with two disciples on the road to Emmaus. They did not recognize Jesus, but listened to Him as "he expounded unto them in all the scriptures the things concerning himself" (Luke 24:27).
After breaking bread with them, Jesus was revealed to the disciples, and vanished from their sight.
Interestingly, they did not say to each other, "We should have known it was Jesus because of his scriptural teaching." Rather, they said:
- Did not our heart burn within us, while he talked with us by the way, and while he opened to us the scriptures?(Luke 24:32)
Would the critics likewise dismiss Jesus' disciples' witness because it was a "burning in the bosom"? Would they characterize this experience as merely the emotional rush of a Hollywood film?
Misunderstanding or mis-stating
Critics fundamentally misunderstand or misstate the LDS revelatory experience if they think it is exclusively or primarily “emotional.” The united witness of mind and heart is key in LDS doctrine.
An LDS “spiritual” experience has as much—or more—intellectual content as it does emotions of peace or joy. Oliver Cowdery received the following revelation through Joseph Smith, and it alludes to previous revelation given to Oliver privately:
- Verily, verily, I say unto you, if you desire a further witness, cast your mind upon the night that you cried unto me in your heart, that you might know concerning the truth of these things.
- Did I not speak peace to your mind concerning the matter? What greater witness can you have than from God? (D&C 6:22–23).
Notice the information spoken to the “mind,” and the peace then follows. And, the solution for later doubts or concerns is not reliance on “a feeling,” but an admonition to recall specific information communicated earlier.
This matches the revelatory pattern explained later to Oliver:
- Behold, you have not understood; you have supposed that I would give it unto you, when you took no thought save it was to ask me.
- But, behold, I say unto you, that you must study it out in your mind; then you must ask me if it be right, and if it is right I will cause that your bosom shall burn within you; therefore, you shall feel that it is right.
- But if it be not right you shall have no such feelings, but you shall have a stupor of thought that shall cause you to forget the thing which is wrong… (D&C 9:7–9).
Again, the united witness of intellect and heart are essential. If either does not agree, then revelation has not confirmed the matter under consideration. Anyone who relies exclusively on a "feeling" does not understand or obey LDS teaching on this matter.
To be sure, many members will talk about how they “felt” when they prayed. It is to fundamentally misunderstand these experiences, however, if we assume (as hostile critics often do) that this talk of “feeling” means simply—or only, or primarily—“emotion.” The LDS member is stymied, in a sense, because there is no good word for what happens that doesn’t also have other secular connotations which critics could misinterpret if they chose.
Hugh Nibley’s description of the critic is apt:
- He cannot conceive how anyone could possibly acquire knowledge by any method other than his. He cannot believe that any man has experienced anything which he has not experienced. . . . ‘I have never seen a vision,' says the [skeptic], ‘therefore, Joseph Smith never had one. I have seen dreams [or had emotionally moving experiences], therefore, I will allow him that.'”[1]
Conclusion
Elder Dallin H. Oaks made the LDS position on revelation and "burning in the bosom" clear:
What does a “burning in the bosom” mean? Does it need to be a feeling of caloric heat, like the burning produced by combustion? If that is the meaning, I have never had a burning in the bosom. Surely, the word “burning” in this scripture signifies a feeling of comfort and serenity. That is the witness many receive. That is the way revelation works.[2]
Ultimately, as the Bible instructs us, we trust in the Lord to reveal the truth:
Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding.
In all thy ways acknowledge him, and he shall direct thy paths. (Prov. 3:5-6)
Endnotes
- [note] Hugh W. Nibley, The World and the Prophets, 3rd edition, (Vol. 3 of Collected Works of Hugh Nibley), edited by John W. Welch, Gary P. Gillum, and Don E. Norton, (Salt Lake City, Utah : Deseret Book Company ; Provo, Utah : Foundation for Ancient Research and Mormon Studies, 1987), 31. ISBN 087579078X. off-site GospeLink (requires subscrip.)
- [note] Dallin H. Oaks, "Teaching and Learning by the Spirit," Ensign (March 1997), 14. off-site
Further reading
FAIR wiki articles
| Holy Ghost wiki articles |
- Anachronistic Holy Ghost in Book of Mormon?
- Burning in the bosom
- Critics claim praying to know the truth is not reliable
- Divinity without a body?
- Identity
- Joseph Smith is the Holy Ghost?
- Moroni's promise
- Testimony and doubt reconciliation
- Will the Holy Ghost receive a body?
FAIR web site
| Holy Ghost FAIR articles on-line |
- FAIR Topical Guide: Holy Ghost FAIR link
- FAIR Topical Guide: Revelation FAIR link
- FAIR Topical Guide: Testimony (Witness of the Holy Ghost) FAIR link
- FAIR Topical Guide: Testing the Book of Mormon FAIR link
- Blake T. Ostler, "Spiritual Experiences as the Basis for Belief and Commitment," (2007 FAIR Conference Presentation). FAIR link
External links
| Holy Ghost on-line articles |
- David A. Bednar, "Seek Learning by Faith," Ensign (September 2007), 60–68 (from talk given to CES educators on 3 February 2006). off-site
- Allen R. Buskirk, "Science, Pseudoscience, and Religious Belief (Review of: The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark)," FARMS Review 17/1 (2005): 273–310. off-site PDF link
- Daniel H. Ludlow, "I Have A Question: A friend of mine says he has prayed about the Book of Mormon but has not received a testimony of its truthfulness. Shouldn't Moroni's promise always work?," Ensign (March 1986), 49. off-site
- Dallin H. Oaks, "How can I distinguish the difference between the promptings of the Holy Ghost and merely my own thoughts, preferences, or hunches?," Ensign (June 1983), 25. off-site
- Dilworth B. Parkinson, "We Have Received, and We Need No More," FARMS Review 17/1 (2005): 255–272. off-site PDF link
- Richard G. Scott, "Using the Supernal Gift of Prayer," Ensign (May 2007), 8–11. off-site off-site
- Gregory L. Smith, "'Days of Miracle and Wonder': The Faith of Sam Harris and the End of Religion, a review of The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason by Sam Harris," FARMS Review 20/1 (2008): 147–174. off-site PDF link wiki
- Richard N. Williams, "Faith, Reason, Knowledge, and Truth," FARMS Review 20/1 (2008): 99–112. off-site PDF link wiki
Printed material
| Holy Ghost print works |
The Foundation for Apologetic Information & Research (FAIR) is a non-profit organization formed in late 1997 for the purpose of defending the Church. FAIR is staffed completely by volunteers, all of whom are dedicated to defending the Church. FAIR is not owned, controlled by, or affiliated with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. All research and opinions provided on this site are the sole responsibility of FAIR and should not be interpreted as official statements of LDS doctrine, belief, or practice.
