
FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
SpencerMarsh (talk | contribs) |
m (→top: Bot replace {{FairMormon}} with {{Main Page}} and remove extra lines around {{Header}}) |
||
(6 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Did Joseph Smith plagiarize John Walker’s a Key to Greek, Latin, and Scripture Proper Names?== | {{Main Page}} | ||
<onlyinclude> | |||
==Question: Did Joseph Smith plagiarize John Walker’s a Key to Greek, Latin, and Scripture Proper Names?== | |||
===There is no evidence that Joseph saw this work.=== | ===There is no evidence that Joseph saw this work.=== | ||
As with most Book of Mormon plagiarism accusations, there is no evidence that Joseph saw this dictionary nor even knew of it. It is unlikely that he turned to such specific sections of the dictionary to rob names from it, even less likely that he was able to employ the names in ways that correspond to the ancient world. This will be discussed in our analysis. | As with most Book of Mormon plagiarism accusations, there is no evidence that Joseph saw this dictionary nor even knew of it. It is unlikely that he turned to such specific sections of the dictionary to rob names from it, even less likely that he was able to employ the names in ways that correspond to the ancient world. This will be discussed in our analysis. | ||
Line 14: | Line 15: | ||
Grunder lists 1-5 names from Walker’s work and then associates them with names in the Book of Mormon that he cites to the right of the last name in each list. It should first be noted that most of the names come from the Old and New Testament as Walker informs us. Some names match up perfectly between the Old and New Testament such as the name “Boaz.” It need not be surprising to find these names in the Book of Mormon as the Book of Mormon claims to be the record of an Israelite people. We might expect to find names that come from the Old Testament—especially those that predate the Lehites departure from Jerusalem. | Grunder lists 1-5 names from Walker’s work and then associates them with names in the Book of Mormon that he cites to the right of the last name in each list. It should first be noted that most of the names come from the Old and New Testament as Walker informs us. Some names match up perfectly between the Old and New Testament such as the name “Boaz.” It need not be surprising to find these names in the Book of Mormon as the Book of Mormon claims to be the record of an Israelite people. We might expect to find names that come from the Old Testament—especially those that predate the Lehites departure from Jerusalem. | ||
===Some names are not found in the Old or New Testament because they are Latin | ===Some names are not found in the Old or New Testament because they are simply other Latin or Greek names=== | ||
Walker also tells us in the title that we will find Latin and Greek Names in the dictionary, yet those that we do find do not correlate well with the Book of Mormon. These will be pointed out below. | Walker also tells us in the title that we will find Latin and Greek Names in the dictionary, yet those that we do find do not correlate well with the Book of Mormon. These will be pointed out below. | ||
There are two positions that we might take when viewing these names: | There are two positions that we might take when viewing these names: | ||
Line 23: | Line 23: | ||
# As believers, that Joseph translated authentic names from an ancient record. | # As believers, that Joseph translated authentic names from an ancient record. | ||
From this analysis, the second position seems more likely. Like the pendant names mentioned before, some names hold remarkable ancient parallels or follow very specific and fascinating patterns. These will be described below when a name does not come from either the Old or New Testament. For names that Grunder associates with Jaredite names, we cannot offer any such study on the names seeing that the language of the Jaredites is not known. Some names have been studied and offer some fascinating insights such as the name “[https://onoma.lib.byu.edu/index.php/DESERET/ Deseret]” in Ether 2:3. For most others, we cannot offer any such study. For those name that are exact matches that occur in the Old or New Testament, we will likewise offer no such study as they are obviously Semitic names. The studies on these names come from the Book of Mormon Onomasticon project done by Brigham Young University and the FairMormon Book of Mormon Evidence page. Like many other Semitic and Egyptian evidence in the Book of Mormon, they are especially fascinating considering that, according to documented evidence, Joseph did not undertake any academic study of the any language until March 1835. He did not study Hebrew until 1836 under Joshua Seixas nor did he attempt to perform any study of the Egyptian language until after the completion of the Book of Abraham in 1842. | From this analysis, the second position seems more likely. Like the pendant names mentioned before, some names hold remarkable ancient parallels or follow very specific and fascinating patterns. These will be described below when a name does not come from either the Old or New Testament. For names that Grunder associates with Jaredite names, we cannot offer any such study on the names seeing that the language of the Jaredites is not known. Some names have been studied and offer some fascinating insights such as the name “[https://onoma.lib.byu.edu/index.php/DESERET/ Deseret]” in Ether 2:3. For most others, we cannot offer any such study. For those name that are exact matches that occur in the Old or New Testament, we will likewise offer no such study as they are obviously Semitic names. The studies on these names come from the Book of Mormon Onomasticon project done by Brigham Young University and the FairMormon Book of Mormon Evidence page. Like many other Semitic and Egyptian evidence in the Book of Mormon, they are especially fascinating considering that, according to documented evidence, Joseph did not undertake any academic study of the any language until March 1835. He did not study Hebrew until 1836 under Joshua Seixas nor did he attempt to perform any study of the Egyptian language until after the completion of the Book of Abraham in 1842. | ||
Nearly all of these names have authentic etymologies and were employed in the Book of Mormon in an authentic way. Some etymologies have still not been offered for a select few. We encourage the reader to visit the following pages to research these names and for positive evidence against this claim: | |||
*[https://onoma.lib.byu.edu/index.php/Main_Page/ The Book of Mormon Onomasticon Project] (The most comprehensive and scholarly resource for studying all names in the Book of Mormon) | |||
*[https://www.fairmormon.org/evidences/Category:Book_of_Mormon/ the FairMormon Book of Mormon Evidence Page] | |||
*[https://bookofmormoncentral.org/ Book of Mormon Central] | |||
p. [71]: | p. [71]: | ||
*A-bin´ a-dab (cf. Abinadi)—The name "Abinadab" occurs 11 times in the Old Testament | *A-bin´ a-dab (cf. Abinadi)—The name "Abinadab" occurs 11 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** 2 Samuel 6:3 | ** 2 Samuel 6:3 | ||
** 1 Samuel 16:8 | ** 1 Samuel 16:8 | ||
Line 31: | Line 37: | ||
** 1 Samuel 7:1 | ** 1 Samuel 7:1 | ||
** 1 Samuel 17:13 | ** 1 Samuel 17:13 | ||
* A-bin´ o-am (cf. Abinadom)—The name "Abinoam" occurs 4 times in the Old Testament (Book of Judges) | * A-bin´ o-am (cf. Abinadom)—The name "Abinoam" occurs 4 times in the Old Testament (Book of Judges). | ||
** Judges 4:12 | ** Judges 4:12 | ||
** Judges 5:1 | ** Judges 5:1 | ||
** Judges 5:12 | ** Judges 5:12 | ||
** Judges 4:6 | ** Judges 4:6 | ||
* A-bish´ a-i (cf. Abish)—The name "Abishai" does not occur in the Bible | * A-bish´ a-i (cf. Abish)—The name "Abishai" does not occur in the Bible. | ||
* A´ chish (cf. Akish)—The name "Achish" occurs 18 times in the Old Testament. | * A´ chish (cf. Akish)—The name "Achish" occurs 18 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** 1 Samuel 28:2 | ** 1 Samuel 28:2 | ||
** 1 Samuel 21:10 | ** 1 Samuel 21:10 | ||
Line 90: | Line 96: | ||
* A´ mal, - the name “Amal” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament | * A´ mal, - the name “Amal” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament | ||
** 1 Chronicles 7:35 | ** 1 Chronicles 7:35 | ||
* A-mal´ da (cf. Alma) – the name Amalda does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament | * A-mal´ da (cf. Alma) – the name Amalda does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. | ||
* Am´ a-lek (cf. Amaleki) – the name “Amalek” can be found 25 times in the Old Testament | * Am´ a-lek (cf. Amaleki) – the name “Amalek” can be found 25 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** Genesis 36: 12, 16, | ** Genesis 36: 12, 16, | ||
** Exodus 17: 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 16 | ** Exodus 17: 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 16 | ||
Line 142: | Line 148: | ||
** 1 Chronicles 11:39 | ** 1 Chronicles 11:39 | ||
** 2 Chronicles 20:1 | ** 2 Chronicles 20:1 | ||
* Am´ non (cf. Amnor) – the name “Amnon” occurs 28 times in the Old Testament | * Am´ non (cf. Amnor) – the name “Amnon” occurs 28 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** 2 Samuel 3: 2; 13: 1, 2 (twice), 3, 4, 6 (twice), 7, 8, 9, 10 (twice), 15 (twice), 20, 22 (twice), 26, 27, 28 (twice), 29, 32, 33, 39 | ** 2 Samuel 3: 2; 13: 1, 2 (twice), 3, 4, 6 (twice), 7, 8, 9, 10 (twice), 15 (twice), 20, 22 (twice), 26, 27, 28 (twice), 29, 32, 33, 39 | ||
** 1 Chronicles 3: 1; 4:20 | ** 1 Chronicles 3: 1; 4:20 | ||
* Am´ o-rites (cf. Amoron) the tribal name “Amorite[s]” occurs 92 times in the Old Testament | * Am´ o-rites (cf. Amoron) the tribal name “Amorite[s]” occurs 92 times in the Old Testament. | ||
* An-a-ni´ ah (cf. Ammonihah) – the name “Ananiah” can be found 2 times in the Old Testament | * An-a-ni´ ah (cf. Ammonihah) – the name “Ananiah” can be found 2 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** Nehemiah 3: 23; 11: 32 | ** Nehemiah 3: 23; 11: 32 | ||
* An´ ti-och (cf. Antion) – the name “Antioch” occurs 19 times in the New Testament | * An´ ti-och (cf. Antion) – the name “Antioch” occurs 19 times in the New Testament. | ||
** Acts 6: 5; 11: 19,20, 22, 26, 27,; 13: 1, 14; 19, 21, 26; 15: 22, 23, 30, 35; 18: 22 | ** Acts 6: 5; 11: 19,20, 22, 26, 27,; 13: 1, 14; 19, 21, 26; 15: 22, 23, 30, 35; 18: 22 | ||
** Galatians 2: 11 | ** Galatians 2: 11 | ||
** 2 Timothy 3: 11 | ** 2 Timothy 3: 11 | ||
* An-ti´ o-chus (cf. Antionum) – “Antiochus Epiphanes” is the name of a King of Syria who ruled between 175-164 B.C. at a time when Palestine was a Syrian province. His name does not occur in the Bible | * An-ti´ o-chus (cf. Antionum) – “Antiochus Epiphanes” is the name of a King of Syria who ruled between 175-164 B.C. at a time when Palestine was a Syrian province. His name does not occur in the Bible. | ||
* AN´ TI-PAS – the name “Antipas” occurs 1 time in the New Testament. | * AN´ TI-PAS – the name “Antipas” occurs 1 time in the New Testament. | ||
** Revelation 2: 13 | ** Revelation 2: 13 | ||
* An to´ ni-a (cf. Antionah) – The name “Antonia” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. The Castle Antonia was built in the stead of the temple at Jerusalem when taken by Herod under the Macabees | * An to´ ni-a (cf. Antionah) – The name “Antonia” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. The Castle Antonia was built in the stead of the temple at Jerusalem when taken by Herod under the Macabees . | ||
* Ar-che-la´ us (cf. Archeantus) – the name “Archelaus” occurs 1 time in the New Testament. | * Ar-che-la´ us (cf. Archeantus) – the name “Archelaus” occurs 1 time in the New Testament. | ||
p. 74: | p. 74: | ||
* BO´ AZ | * BO´ AZ | ||
p. 75: | p. 75: | ||
* Che´ mosh (cf. Chemish) – the name “Chemosh” occurs 8 times in the Old Testament | * Che´ mosh (cf. Chemish) – the name “Chemosh” occurs 8 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** Numbers 21: 29 | ** Numbers 21: 29 | ||
** Judges 11: 24 | ** Judges 11: 24 | ||
Line 172: | Line 177: | ||
** Joshua 15: 30 | ** Joshua 15: 30 | ||
* Che´ sud, - the name “Chesud” does not occur in the Old or New Testament | * Che´ sud, - the name “Chesud” does not occur in the Old or New Testament | ||
* Che´ zib (cf. Shez) - the name “Chezib” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament. The name “Shez” is a Jaredite name and | * Che´ zib (cf. Shez) - the name “Chezib” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament. The name “Shez” is a Jaredite name and no study of its etymology exists. | ||
** Genesis 38: 5 | ** Genesis 38: 5 | ||
* Con-o-ni´ ah (cf. Cumenihah) – the name “Cononiah” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament | * Con-o-ni´ ah (cf. Cumenihah) – the name “Cononiah” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** 2 Chronicles 31: 12,13 | ** 2 Chronicles 31: 12,13 | ||
p. 76: | p. 76: | ||
* Em´ mer [and,] - the name “Emmer” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament | * Em´ mer [and,] - the name “Emmer” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament | ||
* E´ mor (cf. Emer) – the name “Emor” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. | * E´ mor (cf. Emer) – the name “Emor” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. | ||
* ES´ ROM – the name “Esrom” occurs 3 times in the New Testament | * ES´ ROM – the name “Esrom” occurs 3 times in the New Testament | ||
** Matthew 1: 3 (twice) | ** Matthew 1: 3 (twice) | ||
** Luke 3: 33 | ** Luke 3: 33 | ||
* E´ tham (cf. Ethem) – the name Etham occurs 4 times in the Old Testament. The name “Ethem” is a Jaredite name. No study of etymology exists. | * E´ tham (cf. Ethem) – the name Etham occurs 4 times in the Old Testament. The name “Ethem” is a Jaredite name. No study of its etymology exists. | ||
** Exodus 13: 20 | ** Exodus 13: 20 | ||
** Numbers 33: 6 | ** Numbers 33: 6 | ||
* E´ THER – the name “Ether” occurs 2 in the Old Testament | * E´ THER – the name “Ether” occurs 2 in the Old Testament | ||
** Joshua 15: 42; 19:7 | ** Joshua 15: 42; 19:7 | ||
* E-ZI´ AS – the name “Ezias” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament | * E-ZI´ AS – the name “Ezias” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. | ||
* Ez´ ron (cf. Ezrom) – the name “Ezron” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. | * Ez´ ron (cf. Ezrom) – the name “Ezron” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. | ||
* Ga´ di (cf. Gad, Gadianton) – the name “Gadi” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament | * Ga´ di (cf. Gad, Gadianton) – the name “Gadi” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** 2 Kings 15: 14, 17 | ** 2 Kings 15: 14, 17 | ||
* Ga-ze´ ra [and,] – the name “Gazera” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. | * Ga-ze´ ra [and,] – the name “Gazera” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. | ||
* Gaz´ zam (cf. Gazelem) – the name “Gazzam” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament | * Gaz´ zam (cf. Gazelem) – the name “Gazzam” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** Ezra 2: 48 | ** Ezra 2: 48 | ||
** Nehemiah 7: 51 | ** Nehemiah 7: 51 | ||
* Ger´ shon (cf. Jershon) – the name “Gershon” occurs 18 times in the Old Testament | * Ger´ shon (cf. Jershon) – the name “Gershon” occurs 18 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** Genesis 46: 11 | ** Genesis 46: 11 | ||
** Exodus 6: 16, 17 | ** Exodus 6: 16, 17 | ||
Line 201: | Line 206: | ||
** Joshua 21: 6, 27 | ** Joshua 21: 6, 27 | ||
** 1 Chronicles 6: 1; 23: 6 | ** 1 Chronicles 6: 1; 23: 6 | ||
* Gid-e-o´ ni (cf. Giddianhi) – the name “Gideoni” occurs 5 times in the Old Testament. | * Gid-e-o´ ni (cf. Giddianhi) – the name “Gideoni” occurs 5 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** Numbers 1: 11; 2: 22; 7: 60, 65; 10:24 | ** Numbers 1: 11; 2: 22; 7: 60, 65; 10:24 | ||
* GIL´ E-AD – the name “Gilead” occurs 134 times in the Old Testament | * GIL´ E-AD – the name “Gilead” occurs 134 times in the Old Testament | ||
* GIL´ GAL – the name “Gilgal” occurs 42 times in the Old Testament | * GIL´ GAL – the name “Gilgal” occurs 42 times in the Old Testament | ||
* GO-MOR´ RAH (cf. Cumorah, both sites of massive destruction of the wicked) – the name “Gomorrah” occurs 21 times in the Old Testament | * GO-MOR´ RAH (cf. Cumorah, both sites of massive destruction of the wicked) – the name “Gomorrah” occurs 21 times in the Old Testament. | ||
* Hag´ gith (cf. Hagoth) – the name “Haggith” occurs 5 times in the Old Testament | * Hag´ gith (cf. Hagoth) – the name “Haggith” occurs 5 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** 2 Samuel 3: 4 | ** 2 Samuel 3: 4 | ||
** 1 Kings 1: 5; 2: 13 | ** 1 Kings 1: 5; 2: 13 | ||
Line 212: | Line 217: | ||
* HE´ LAM – the name “Helam” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament | * HE´ LAM – the name “Helam” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament | ||
** 2 Samuel 10:16 | ** 2 Samuel 10:16 | ||
* He´ man (cf. Helaman) – the name “Heman” occurs 17 times in the Old Testament | * He´ man (cf. Helaman) – the name “Heman” occurs 17 times in the Old Testament. | ||
* Her´ mon-ites (cf. Hermounts) – the tribal name “Hermonite[s]” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament. | * Her´ mon-ites (cf. Hermounts) – the tribal name “Hermonite[s]” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament. | ||
** Psalms 42: 6 | ** Psalms 42: 6 | ||
* Hesh´ bon [and,] – the name “Heshbon” occurs 38 times in the Old Testament | * Hesh´ bon [and,] – the name “Heshbon” occurs 38 times in the Old Testament | ||
* Hesh´ mon, - the name “Heshmon” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament | * Hesh´ mon, - the name “Heshmon” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament | ||
** Joshua 15: 27 | ** Joshua 15: 27 | ||
* Heth´ lon (cf. Heshlon) – the name “Hethlon” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament. The name “Heshlon” is Jaredite however, an etymology has been proposed | * Heth´ lon (cf. Heshlon) – the name “Hethlon” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament. The name “Heshlon” is Jaredite however, an etymology has been proposed. | ||
** Ezekiel 47: 15; 48: 1 | ** Ezekiel 47: 15; 48: 1 | ||
* [I´ RAD - see Moses 5 (p. 79; - the name “Irad” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament and in the same context as the Book of Moses. | * [I´ RAD - see Moses 5 (p. 79; - the name “Irad” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament and in the same context as the Book of Moses. | ||
Line 228: | Line 233: | ||
** Psalms 83: 6 | ** Psalms 83: 6 | ||
p. 78: | p. 78: | ||
* Ja´ kim (cf. Jacom) – the name “Jakim” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament. The name “Jacom” is Jaredite however, an etymology has been proposed | * Ja´ kim (cf. Jacom) – the name “Jakim” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament. The name “Jacom” is Jaredite however, an etymology has been proposed. | ||
** 1 Chronicles 8: 19; 24: 12 | ** 1 Chronicles 8: 19; 24: 12 | ||
* Ja´ num (cf. Jeneum) – the name “Janum” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament. The name “Jeneum” appears to be a scribal misspelling of the name “Joneum”. More information on the name “Joneum” may be found | * Ja´ num (cf. Jeneum) – the name “Janum” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament. The name “Jeneum” appears to be a scribal misspelling of the name “Joneum”. More information on the name “Joneum” may be found at the sites above. | ||
** Joshua 15: 53 | ** Joshua 15: 53 | ||
* JA´RED – the name “Jared” occurs 5 times in the Old Testament and 1 time in the New Testament | * JA´RED – the name “Jared” occurs 5 times in the Old Testament and 1 time in the New Testament | ||
** Genesis 5: 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 | ** Genesis 5: 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 | ||
** Luke 3:37 | ** Luke 3:37 | ||
* Ja´ shen (cf. Jashon) – the name “Jashen” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament | * Ja´ shen (cf. Jashon) – the name “Jashen” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament. | ||
* 2 Samuel 23: 32 | * 2 Samuel 23: 32 | ||
p. 79: | p. 79: | ||
Line 252: | Line 257: | ||
* Kor´ hites, - see “Korhite” | * Kor´ hites, - see “Korhite” | ||
* Kor´ ites – the tribal name “Korite[s]” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament | * Kor´ ites – the tribal name “Korite[s]” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament | ||
* Ko´ re (cf. Korihor, Corihor) – the name “Kore” occurs 4 times in the Old Testament. The name “Korihor” appears to be a Lehite adoption of the Jaredite name “Corihor” | * Ko´ re (cf. Korihor, Corihor) – the name “Kore” occurs 4 times in the Old Testament. The name “Korihor” appears to be a Lehite adoption of the Jaredite name “Corihor”. | ||
** 1 Chronicles 9: 19; 26: 1, 19 | ** 1 Chronicles 9: 19; 26: 1, 19 | ||
** 2 Chronicles 31:14 | ** 2 Chronicles 31:14 | ||
* LA´ BAN – the name “Laban” occurs 60 times in the Old Testament | * LA´ BAN – the name “Laban” occurs 60 times in the Old Testament | ||
* La-cu´ nus (cf. Lachoneus) – the name “Lacunus” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament | * La-cu´ nus (cf. Lachoneus) – the name “Lacunus” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. | ||
* Lah´ man (cf. Laman) – the name “Lahman” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament | * Lah´ man (cf. Laman) – the name “Lahman” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. | ||
* [LA´ MECH - see Moses 5] – the name “Lamech” occurs 12 times in the Old Testament | * [LA´ MECH - see Moses 5] – the name “Lamech” occurs 12 times in the Old Testament | ||
** Genesis 4: 18, 19, 23 (twice), 24; 5: 25, 26, 28, 30, 31 | ** Genesis 4: 18, 19, 23 (twice), 24; 5: 25, 26, 28, 30, 31 | ||
* LE´ HI * - the name “Lehi” occurs 4 times in the Old Testament. This name was primarily known as a place name. Evidence for the name “Lehi” as a personal name | * LE´ HI * - the name “Lehi” occurs 4 times in the Old Testament. This name was primarily known as a place name. Evidence for the name “Lehi” as a personal name has surfaced in recent years. | ||
** Judges 15: 9, 14, 17 (“Rameth-lehi”), 19 | ** Judges 15: 9, 14, 17 (“Rameth-lehi”), 19 | ||
* LEM´ U-EL * - the name “Lemuel” occurs 2 in the Old Testament. | * LEM´ U-EL * - the name “Lemuel” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament. | ||
** Proverbs 31: 1, 4 | ** Proverbs 31: 1, 4 | ||
* Lib´ nah (cf. Limnah) – the name “Libnah” occurs 18 times in the Old Testament | * Lib´ nah (cf. Limnah) – the name “Libnah” occurs 18 times in the Old Testament. | ||
* Lib´ ni [and,] – the name “Libni” occurs 5 times in the Old Testament | * Lib´ ni [and,] – the name “Libni” occurs 5 times in the Old Testament | ||
** Exodus 6: 17 | ** Exodus 6: 17 | ||
Line 299: | Line 304: | ||
* Ne´ ah (cf. Neas) – the name “Neah” occurs in the 1 in the Old Testament | * Ne´ ah (cf. Neas) – the name “Neah” occurs in the 1 in the Old Testament | ||
** Joshua 19: 13 | ** Joshua 19: 13 | ||
* Ne´ cho (designated a Book of Abraham mummy; see MP 49, Belknap) – the name “Necho” occurs 4 times in the Old Testament | * Ne´ cho (designated a Book of Abraham mummy; see MP 49, Belknap) – the name “Necho” occurs 4 times in the Old Testament. It was the name of an Egyptian king. | ||
** 2 Chronicles 35: 20; 36:4 | ** 2 Chronicles 35: 20; 36:4 | ||
* Ne´ hum (cf. Neum) – the name “Nehum” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament | * Ne´ hum (cf. Neum) – the name “Nehum” occurs 1 time in the Old Testament | ||
** Nehemiah 7: 7 | ** Nehemiah 7: 7 | ||
* NE´ PHI * the name “Nephi” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. The name Nephi is a remarkable name in the Book of Mormon | * NE´ PHI * the name “Nephi” does not occur in the Old Testament or New Testament. The name Nephi is a remarkable name in the Book of Mormon--a way that was unlikely for Joseph to have known about. | ||
* NIM´ RAH – the name “Nimrah” occurs 3 times in the Old Testament | * NIM´ RAH – the name “Nimrah” occurs 3 times in the Old Testament | ||
** Numbers 32: 3, 36. | ** Numbers 32: 3, 36. | ||
Line 338: | Line 343: | ||
* Sar-a-i´ ah (cf. Sariah) – the name “Saraiah” does not occur in the Old Testament | * Sar-a-i´ ah (cf. Sariah) – the name “Saraiah” does not occur in the Old Testament | ||
p. 83: | p. 83: | ||
* Se´ nir (cf. Senine) – the name “Senir” occurs 2 times in the Old Testament | * Se´ nir (cf. Senine) – the name “Senir” occurs 2 times in the Old or New Testament | ||
** 1 Chronicles 5: 23 | ** 1 Chronicles 5: 23 | ||
** Ezekiel 27: 5 | ** Ezekiel 27: 5 | ||
Line 442: | Line 447: | ||
* [http://www.mormoninterpreter.com/finding-parallels-some-cautions-and-criticisms-part-one/ Finding Parallels: Some Cautions and Criticisms Part One] | * [http://www.mormoninterpreter.com/finding-parallels-some-cautions-and-criticisms-part-one/ Finding Parallels: Some Cautions and Criticisms Part One] | ||
* [http://www.mormoninterpreter.com/finding-parallels-some-cautions-and-criticisms-part-two/ Finding Parallels: Some Cautions and Criticisms Part Two] | * [http://www.mormoninterpreter.com/finding-parallels-some-cautions-and-criticisms-part-two/ Finding Parallels: Some Cautions and Criticisms Part Two] | ||
</onlyinclude> | |||
{{endnotes sources}} | |||
[[Category:Questions]] |
As with most Book of Mormon plagiarism accusations, there is no evidence that Joseph saw this dictionary nor even knew of it. It is unlikely that he turned to such specific sections of the dictionary to rob names from it, even less likely that he was able to employ the names in ways that correspond to the ancient world. This will be discussed in our analysis.
Rick Grunder in his book attempts to show names that Joseph may have used when translating the Book of Mormon and restoring the Books of Moses by citing John Walker’s “A Key to Greek, Latin, and Scripture Proper Names”. Grunder cites his methodology as follows:
I have selected the following list of names and terms which I find similar to, resonant with, or identical to Book of Mormon names. On page 79 alone appear not only the three eldest male members of the leading Book of Mormon family (Lehi, ‘Lah’man’ and Lemuel), but the Book’s first villain as well (Laban), plus two notable Master Mahan/secret combination protagonists in Joseph Smith’s 1830 Book of Moses (chapter 5): Lamech and Irad. Walker’s Key also provides the unusual reference to the Apocryphal name Nephi, p. 81. Of additional interest is a pronunciation rule to which ‘Ne´ phi’ is here referenced, showing the same pronunciation that is used by Mormons today.
In preparing this list, I have excluded a number of the most famous biblical names shared or recalled by Book of Mormon people, as well as the names of exclusively biblical locations referred to in the Book of Mormon (primarily in 2 Nephi). Names which I place in LARGE & SMALL CAPITAL LETTERS, (not followed by comparison names in parentheses) are identical to names in the Book of Mormon. Names which I signal with an asterisk (*) occur in Walker’s Key with added prominence by appearing first or last in a page column.
Grunder lists 1-5 names from Walker’s work and then associates them with names in the Book of Mormon that he cites to the right of the last name in each list. It should first be noted that most of the names come from the Old and New Testament as Walker informs us. Some names match up perfectly between the Old and New Testament such as the name “Boaz.” It need not be surprising to find these names in the Book of Mormon as the Book of Mormon claims to be the record of an Israelite people. We might expect to find names that come from the Old Testament—especially those that predate the Lehites departure from Jerusalem.
Walker also tells us in the title that we will find Latin and Greek Names in the dictionary, yet those that we do find do not correlate well with the Book of Mormon. These will be pointed out below.
There are two positions that we might take when viewing these names:
From this analysis, the second position seems more likely. Like the pendant names mentioned before, some names hold remarkable ancient parallels or follow very specific and fascinating patterns. These will be described below when a name does not come from either the Old or New Testament. For names that Grunder associates with Jaredite names, we cannot offer any such study on the names seeing that the language of the Jaredites is not known. Some names have been studied and offer some fascinating insights such as the name “Deseret” in Ether 2:3. For most others, we cannot offer any such study. For those name that are exact matches that occur in the Old or New Testament, we will likewise offer no such study as they are obviously Semitic names. The studies on these names come from the Book of Mormon Onomasticon project done by Brigham Young University and the FairMormon Book of Mormon Evidence page. Like many other Semitic and Egyptian evidence in the Book of Mormon, they are especially fascinating considering that, according to documented evidence, Joseph did not undertake any academic study of the any language until March 1835. He did not study Hebrew until 1836 under Joshua Seixas nor did he attempt to perform any study of the Egyptian language until after the completion of the Book of Abraham in 1842.
Nearly all of these names have authentic etymologies and were employed in the Book of Mormon in an authentic way. Some etymologies have still not been offered for a select few. We encourage the reader to visit the following pages to research these names and for positive evidence against this claim:
p. [71]:
p. 72:
p. 74:
p. 75:
p. 76:
p. 78:
p. 79:
p. 80:
p. 81:
p. 82:
p. 83:
p. 84:
p. 85:
Benjamin McGuire reviews the rest of Grunder's work in Mormon Parallels in these two articles published by Interpreter: A Journal of Mormon Scripture
Notes
FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
We are a volunteer organization. We invite you to give back.
Donate Now