Difference between revisions of "Criticism of Mormonism/Books/One Nation Under Gods/Use of sources"
m (→‎top: Bot replace {{FairMormon}} with {{Main Page}} and remove extra lines around {{Header}})
 
(29 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
__NOTOC__
+
{{Main Page}}
−
{{FAIRAnalysisHeader
+
{{H1
−
|title=[[../]]
+
|L=Criticism of Mormonism/Books/One Nation Under Gods/Use of sources
−
|author=Richard Abanes
+
|H=''One Nation Under Gods'': Source Analysis, Sorted by Page Number
−
|noauthor=
+
|S=
−
|section=Use of Sources
+
|L1=
−
|previous=[[../Index|Index of Claims]]
+
|T=[[../|One Nation Under Gods]]
−
|next=[[../Loaded and prejudicial language|Loaded and prejudicial language]]
+
|A=Richard Abanes
−
|notes={{AuthorsDisclaimer}}
+
|<=[[../Index|Index of Claims]]
 +
|>=[[../Loaded and prejudicial language|Loaded and prejudicial language]]
 
}}
 
}}
−
=Source Analysis, Sorted by Page Number=
+
 
 
All page numbers are currently from the paperback edition of ''One Nation under Gods'' (New York: Four Walls Eight Windows, 2002), except where noted.
 
All page numbers are currently from the paperback edition of ''One Nation under Gods'' (New York: Four Walls Eight Windows, 2002), except where noted.
−
 
+
{{SummaryItem
−
{{BeginSourceTable}}
+
|link=Criticism of Mormonism/Books/One Nation Under Gods/Use of sources/Dallin H. Oaks on God
−
|
+
|subject=Dallin H. Oaks on God
−
====xv (HB)====
+
|summary=One critic of Mormonism claims that Dallin Oaks told Mormons in 1995 "that so-called Christianity sees God as an entirely different kind of being."
−
||Boyd K. Packer||BYU Studies 21:264-265||[[/Historical Suppression in the Church|Historical Suppression in the Church]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=Criticism of Mormonism/Books/One Nation Under Gods/Use of sources/Historical Suppression in the Church
−
====xv (HB)====
+
|subject=Historical Suppression in the Church  
−
||Allen Roberts||Private Eye Weekly||[[/Calling All Mormon Scholars|Calling All Mormon Scholars]]
+
|summary=xv (HB): Boyd K. Packer, BYU Studies 21:264-265
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
 
+
|link=/Calling All Mormon Scholars
−
====xvi (HB)====
+
|subject=Calling All Mormon Scholars
−
||John E. Hallwas and Roger D. Launius||Cultures in Conflict||[[/An Example of Biased Histories|An Example of Biased Histories]]
+
|summary=xv (HB): Allen Roberts, Private Eye Weekly
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====xviii (HB)====
+
|link=/An Example of Biased Histories
−
||Fred Esplin||Utah Holiday||[[/The Mormon Quest for Power|The Mormon Quest for Power]]
+
|subject=An Example of Biased Histories
−
|-
+
|summary=xvi (HB): John E. Hallwas and Roger D. Launius, Cultures in Conflict  
−
|
+
}}
−
====xx (HB)====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
||Fred Esplin||Utah Holiday||[[/Perception and Reality|Perception and Reality]]
+
|link=/The Mormon Quest for Power
−
|-
+
|subject=The Mormon Quest for Power
−
|
+
|summary=xviii (HB): Fred Esplin, Utah Holiday
−
====xx (HB)====
+
}}
−
||Brigham Young||Journal of Discourses 11:249||[[/Christ Setting up a Theocracy in Missouri|Christ Setting up a Theocracy in Missouri]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Perception and Reality
−
|
+
|subject=Perception and Reality
−
====xxi (HB)====
+
|summary=xx (HB): Fred Esplin, Utah Holiday
−
||Joseph Smith, Jr.||History of the Church||[[/Destroying Governments and Religions|Destroying Governments and Religions]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Christ Setting up a Theocracy in Missouri
−
====xxiv (HB)====
+
|subject=Christ Setting up a Theocracy in Missouri
−
||Brigham Young||Journal of Discourses||[[/Morally, ethically, spiritually superior|Morally, ethically, spiritually superior?]]
+
|summary= xx (HB): Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 11:249
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
 
+
|link=/Destroying Governments and Religions
−
====16====
+
|subject=Destroying Governments and Religions
−
||Richard Abanes||---||[[/"This is My Beloved Son"|"This is My Beloved Son"]]
+
|summary= xxi (HB): Joseph Smith, Jr., History of the Church
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====27====
+
|link=/Morally, ethically, spiritually superior
−
||Lucy Mack Smith||"Preliminary Manuscript" of ''Biographical Sketches of Joseph Smith the Prophet, and His Progenitors for many Generations''||[[/Lucy and the angel|Lucy and the angel]]
+
|subject=Morally, ethically, spiritually superior?  
−
|-
+
|summary= xxiv (HB): Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses
−
|
+
}}
−
 
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====53====
+
|link=/"This is My Beloved Son"
−
||Richard Abanes||---||[[/Seeing the Plates|Seeing the Plates]]
+
|subject="This is My Beloved Son"
−
|-
+
|summary=16: Richard Abanes
−
|
+
}}
−
====55====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
||John A. Wilson||Letter to Martin Cowan||[[/Reformed Egyptian|Reformed Egyptian]]
+
|link=/Lucy and the angel
−
|-
+
|subject=Lucy and the angel
−
|
+
|summary=27: Lucy Mack Smith, "Preliminary Manuscript" of ''Biographical Sketches of Joseph Smith the Prophet, and His Progenitors for many Generations''
−
====64====
+
}}
−
||Lucy Mack Smith||Biographical Sketches of Joseph Smith the Prophet, and His Progenitors for many Generations||[[/Tall Tales|Tall Tales]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Seeing the Plates
−
|
+
|subject=Seeing the Plates
−
====72====
+
|summary=53, Richard Abanes
−
||Dan Vogel||Early Mormon Documents||[[/Prophetic Autobiography|Prophetic Autobiography]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Reformed Egyptian
−
====75====
+
|subject=Reformed Egyptian
−
||Dee F. Green||"Book of Mormon Archeology: the Myths and the Alternatives," ''Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought'' ||[[/No Book of Mormon archaeology|No Book of Mormon archaeology]]
+
|summary=55, John A. Wilson, Letter to Martin Cowan
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====86====
+
|link=/Tall Tales
−
||Brigham Young, John Taylor||''Journal of Discourses''||[[/Christianity is satanic|Christianity is satanic]]
+
|subject=Tall Tales
−
|-
+
|summary=64, Lucy Mack Smith, Biographical Sketches of Joseph Smith the Prophet, and His Progenitors for many Generations
−
|
+
}}
−
====89====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Divining rods to Kimball and Young|Divining rods to Kimball and Young]]
+
|link=/Prophetic Autobiography
−
|-
+
|subject=Prophetic Autobiography
−
|
+
|summary=72, Dan Vogel, Early Mormon Documents
−
====95====
+
}}
−
||Albert Chandler||Early Mormon Documents||[[/Those Power-Hungry Mormons|Those Power-Hungry Mormons]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/No Book of Mormon archaeology
−
|
+
|subject=No Book of Mormon archaeology
−
====103n2====
+
|summary=75, Dee F. Green, "Book of Mormon Archeology: the Myths and the Alternatives," ''Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought''
−
|| || ||[[/Distorted account of three degrees of glory|Distorted account of three degrees of glory]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Christianity is satanic
−
 
+
|subject=Christianity is satanic
−
====105====
+
|summary=86, Brigham Young, John Taylor, ''Journal of Discourses''
−
|| || ||[[/Haranguing non-Mormons|Haranguing non-Mormons]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Divining rods to Kimball and Young
−
====110====
+
|subject=Divining rods to Kimball and Young
−
|| || ||[[/Missouri belongs to the Mormons|Missouri belongs to the Mormons]]
+
|summary=89
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====116====
+
|link=/Those Power-Hungry Mormons
−
|| || ||[[/Disobey secular law|Disobey secular law]]
+
|subject=Those Power-Hungry Mormons
−
|-
+
|summary=95: Albert Chandler, Early Mormon Documents
−
|
+
}}
−
 
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====122====
+
|link=/Distorted account of three degrees of glory
−
||Joseph Smith||History of the Church||[[/Redeemed by September 1836|Redeemed by September 1836]]
+
|subject=Distorted account of three degrees of glory
−
|-
+
|summary=103n2
−
|
+
}}
−
====129====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Joseph gave couples marriage certificates|Joseph gave couples marriage certificates]]
+
|link=/Haranguing non-Mormons
−
|-
+
|subject=Haranguing non-Mormons
−
|
+
|summary=105
−
====135====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Joseph owned 144 acres in Kirtland|Joseph owned 144 acres in Kirtland]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Missouri belongs to the Mormons
−
|
+
|subject=Missouri belongs to the Mormons
−
 
+
|summary=110
−
====136====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Warren Parrish and Kirtland Safety Society "revelation"|Warren Parrish and Kirtland Safety Society "revelation"]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Disobey secular law
−
|
+
|subject=Disobey secular law
−
 
+
|summary=116
−
====171====
+
}}
−
||Joseph Smith, Jr.||History of the Church||[[/Joseph Smith's Narcissism|Joseph Smith's Narcissism]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Redeemed by September 1836
−
|
+
|subject=Redeemed by September 1836
−
====174====
+
|summary=122: Joseph Smith, History of the Church
−
||Brigham Young||Journal of Discourses||[[/Joseph on par with Jesus Christ|Brigham Young said that Joseph on par with Jesus Christ?]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Joseph gave couples marriage certificates
−
 
+
|subject=Joseph gave couples marriage certificates
−
====175====
+
|summary=129
−
||Levi Edgar Young||Letter to Sandra Tanner||[[/Thou Shalt Not Raise a False Report|Thou Shalt Not Raise a False Report]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Joseph owned 144 acres in Kirtland
−
====177====
+
|subject=Joseph owned 144 acres in Kirtland
−
||Joseph Smith, Jr.||History of the Church||[[/Joseph's "Grandiose Sense of Self Importance"|Joseph's "Grandiose Sense of Self Importance"]]
+
|summary=135
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====178====
+
|link=/Warren Parrish and Kirtland Safety Society "revelation"
−
||Joseph Smith, Jr.||History of the Church||[[/The Wrestling Prophet|The Wrestling Prophet]]
+
|subject=Warren Parrish and Kirtland Safety Society "revelation"
−
|-
+
|summary=136
−
|
+
}}
−
====179====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
||Joseph Smith, Jr.||History of the Church||[[/America's Fighting Prophet|America's Fighting Prophet]]
+
|link=/Joseph Smith's Narcissism
−
|-
+
|subject=Joseph Smith's Narcissism
−
|
+
|summary=171: Joseph Smith, Jr., History of the Church
−
====179====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Joseph hit a baptist preacher|Joseph hit a baptist preacher]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Joseph on par with Jesus Christ
−
|
+
|subject=Brigham Young said that Joseph on par with Jesus Christ?  
−
 
+
|summary=174: Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses
−
====191====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/D and C 98 justifies murder|D and C 98 justifies murder]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Thou Shalt Not Raise a False Report
−
|
+
|subject=Thou Shalt Not Raise a False Report
−
====192====
+
|summary=175: Levi Edgar Young, Letter to Sandra Tanner
−
|| || ||[[/Rockwell admitting to shooting Boggs|Rockwell admitting to shooting Boggs]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Joseph's "Grandiose Sense of Self Importance"
−
====196====
+
|subject=Joseph's "Grandiose Sense of Self Importance"
−
|| ||History of the Church||[[/Debauchery and despotism at Nauvoo|Debauchery and despotism at Nauvoo]]
+
|summary=177, Joseph Smith, Jr., History of the Church
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====212====
+
|link=/The Wrestling Prophet
−
|| || ||[[/Nauvoo police violence|Nauvoo police violence]]
+
|subject=The Wrestling Prophet
−
|-
+
|summary=178: Joseph Smith, Jr., History of the Church
−
|
+
}}
−
 
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====213====
+
|link=/America's Fighting Prophet
−
|| || ||[[/Killing Lambert Symes|Killing Lambert Symes]]
+
|subject=America's Fighting Prophet
−
|-
+
|summary=179: Joseph Smith, Jr., History of the Church
−
|
+
}}
−
====213====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Irvine Hodge murder|Irvine Hodge murder]]
+
|link=/Joseph hit a baptist preacher
−
|-
+
|subject=Joseph hit a baptist preacher
−
|
+
|summary=179
−
====213====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Other homicides by members of the Council of Fifty|Other homicides by members of the Council of Fifty]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/D and C 98 justifies murder
−
|
+
|subject=D and C 98 justifies murder
−
 
+
|summary=191
−
====213-214====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Flogging those out of fellowship|Flogging those out of fellowship]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Rockwell admitting to shooting Boggs
−
|
+
|subject=Rockwell admitting to shooting Boggs
−
 
+
|summary=192
−
====214====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Whistling and Whittling Brigades|Whistling and Whittling Brigades]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Debauchery and despotism at Nauvoo
−
|
+
|subject=Debauchery and despotism at Nauvoo
−
====216-217====
+
|summary=196: History of the Church
−
|| || ||[[/Counterfeiting apostles and Joseph|Counterfeiting apostles and Joseph]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Nauvoo police violence
−
 
+
|subject=Nauvoo police violence
−
====220====
+
|summary=212
−
||Brigham Young||Journal of Discourses 14:205||[[/Brigham, the Dictator|Brigham, the Dictator]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Killing Lambert Symes
−
====221-222====
+
|subject=Killing Lambert Symes
−
|| || ||[[/Gentiles have no right to property|Gentiles have no right to property]]
+
|summary=213
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
 
+
|link=/Irvine Hodge murder
−
====222====
+
|subject=Irvine Hodge murder
−
||Brigham Young||Journal of Discourses 2:310||[[/Brigham and the Kingdom of God|Brigham and the Kingdom of God]]
+
|summary=213
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====222====
+
|link=/Other homicides by members of the Council of Fifty
−
||Brigham Young||Journal of Discourses 2:317||[[/Ruling Over the Earth|Ruling Over the Earth]]
+
|subject=Other homicides by members of the Council of Fifty
−
|-
+
|summary=213
−
|
+
}}
−
====223====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Ettie V. Smith|Ettie V. Smith]]
+
|link=/Flogging those out of fellowship
−
|-
+
|subject=Flogging those out of fellowship
−
|
+
|summary=213-214
−
====223====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Brigham as President of the United States|Brigham as President of the United States]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Whistling and Whittling Brigades
−
|
+
|subject=Whistling and Whittling Brigades
−
====223====
+
|summary=214
−
|| || ||[[/Church and state all one now|Church and state all one now]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Counterfeiting apostles and Joseph
−
====223====
+
|subject=Counterfeiting apostles and Joseph
−
|| || ||[[/Heber C. Kimball--violence and intimidation|Heber C. Kimball--violence and intimidation]]
+
|summary=216-217
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
 
+
|link=/Brigham, the Dictator
−
====227-228====
+
|subject=Brigham, the Dictator
−
|| || ||[[/Early federal territorial officials|Early federal territorial officials]]
+
|summary=220: Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 14:205
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====233====
+
|link=/Gentiles have no right to property
−
|| || ||[[/Cutting off from the earth|Cutting off from the earth]]
+
|subject=Gentiles have no right to property
−
|-
+
|summary=221-222
−
|
+
}}
−
====234-235====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Murder unfaithful Mormons to save souls|Murder unfaithful Mormons to save souls]]
+
|link=/Brigham and the Kingdom of God
−
|-
+
|subject=Brigham and the Kingdom of God
−
|
+
|summary=222: Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 2:310
−
 
+
}}
−
====235====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Apostles killed Judas|Apostles killed Judas]]
+
|link=/Ruling Over the Earth
−
|-
+
|subject=Ruling Over the Earth
−
|
+
|summary=222: Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 2:317
−
====236 (PB only)====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Brigham and bowie knife|Brigham and bowie knife]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Ettie V. Smith
−
|
+
|subject=Ettie V. Smith
−
 
+
|summary=223
−
====236-237====
+
}}
−
||Brigham Young||Journal of Discourses 2:311||[[/Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"|Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Brigham as President of the United States
−
|
+
|subject=Brigham as President of the United States
−
====245====
+
|summary=223
−
||Brigham Young||Personal letter (1857)||[[/Orders to Starve Gentiles|Orders to Starve Gentiles]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Church and state all one now
−
====245====
+
|subject=Church and state all one now
−
|| || ||[[/Brigham Young ordered MMM|Brigham Young ordered Mountain Meadows Massacre]]
+
|summary=223
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
 
+
|link=/Heber C. Kimball--violence and intimidation
−
====251====
+
|subject=Heber C. Kimball--violence and intimidation
−
|| || ||[[/Brigham Young orders MMM monument demolished|Brigham Young orders MMM monument demolished]]
+
|summary=223
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====260====
+
|link=/Early federal territorial officials
−
|| || ||[[/Blood atone Washington politicians|Blood atone Washington politicians]]
+
|subject=Early federal territorial officials
−
|-
+
|summary=227-228
−
|
+
}}
−
====266====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Saints sole rulers over every government|Saints sole rulers over every government]]
+
|link=/Cutting off from the earth
−
|-
+
|subject=Cutting off from the earth
−
|
+
|summary=233
−
====270====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Attitude of Saints to Civil War prophecy|Attitude of Saints to Civil War prophecy]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Murder unfaithful Mormons to save souls
−
|
+
|subject=Murder unfaithful Mormons to save souls
−
 
+
|summary=234-235
−
====270====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Hyde on US to be divided|Hyde on US to be divided]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Apostles killed Judas
−
|
+
|subject=Apostles killed Judas
−
====271====
+
|summary=235
−
|| || ||[[/Beating John W. Dawson|Beating John W. Dawson]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Brigham and bowie knife
−
====271====
+
|subject=Brigham and bowie knife
−
|| || ||[[/Too much education damaging|Too much education damaging]]
+
|summary=236 (PB only)
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====287====
+
|link=/Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"
−
|| || ||[[/Conception of Christ|Conception of Christ]]
+
|subject=Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"
−
|-
+
|summary=236-237: Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 2:311
−
|
+
}}
−
 
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====289====
+
|link=/Orders to Starve Gentiles
−
||Eugene England||Dialogue (Winter 1987)||[[/LDS "Birth Machines"|LDS "Birth Machines"]]
+
|subject=Orders to Starve Gentiles
−
|-
+
|summary=245: Brigham Young, Personal letter (1857)
−
|
+
}}
−
====295====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Wife swapping|Wife swapping]]
+
|link=/Brigham Young ordered MMM
−
|-
+
|subject=Brigham Young ordered Mountain Meadows Massacre
−
|
+
|summary=245
−
====301====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Damned without plural marriage|Damned without plural marriage]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Brigham Young orders MMM monument demolished
−
|
+
|subject=Brigham Young orders MMM monument demolished
−
 
+
|summary=251
−
====316====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/John Taylor September 1886 revelation|John Taylor September 1886 revelation]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Blood atone Washington politicians
−
|
+
|subject=Blood atone Washington politicians
−
====317====
+
|summary=260
−
|| || ||[[/Polygamy absolutely essential to godhood|Polygamy absolutely essential to godhood]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Saints sole rulers over every government
−
 
+
|subject=Saints sole rulers over every government
−
====320====
+
|summary=266
−
|| || ||[[/Demolish Endowment House|Wilford Woodruff demolished Endowment House?]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Attitude of Saints to Civil War prophecy
−
====325====
+
|subject=Attitude of Saints to Civil War prophecy
−
|| || ||[[/Above the law|Above the law]]
+
|summary=270
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====331====
+
|link=/Hyde on US to be divided
−
|| || ||[[/Approved marriages 1890-1899|Approved marriages 1890-1899]]
+
|subject=Hyde on US to be divided
−
|-
+
|summary=270
−
|
+
}}
−
 
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====334====
+
|link=/Beating John W. Dawson
−
|| || ||[[/Vengeance hymns|Vengeance hymns]]
+
|subject=Beating John W. Dawson
−
|-
+
|summary=271
−
|
+
}}
−
====339====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Joseph F. Smith finally admits|Joseph F. Smith finally admits]]
+
|link=/Too much education damaging
−
|-
+
|subject=Too much education damaging
−
|
+
|summary=271
−
====355-372====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Double standard on race|Double standard on race]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Conception of Christ
−
|
+
|subject=Conception of Christ
−
 
+
|summary=287
−
====358-360====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Mormon Doctrine and race issues|Mormon Doctrine and race issues]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/LDS "Birth Machines"
−
|
+
|subject=LDS "Birth Machines"
−
====379-380====
+
|summary=289: Eugene England, Dialogue (Winter 1987)
−
|| || ||[[/Special relationship with Christ|Special relationship with Christ]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Wife swapping
−
 
+
|subject=Wife swapping
−
====380====
+
|summary=295
−
|| || ||[[/Natural before spiritual|Natural before spiritual]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Damned without plural marriage
−
 
+
|subject=Damned without plural marriage
−
====383-384====
+
|summary=301
−
|| || ||[[/Orson Pratt condemns the Bible|Orson Pratt condemns the Bible]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/John Taylor September 1886 revelation
−
 
+
|subject=John Taylor September 1886 revelation
−
====389====
+
|summary=316
−
||Gordon B. Hinckley||General Conference (1997)||[[/Gordon B. Hinckley Understands Doctrine|Gordon B. Hinckley Understands Doctrine]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Polygamy absolutely essential to godhood
−
====406====
+
|subject=Polygamy absolutely essential to godhood
−
|| || ||[[/Forged Rocky Mountain prophecy|Forged Rocky Mountain prophecy]]
+
|summary=317
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====406====
+
|link=/Demolish Endowment House
−
|| || ||[[/Stephen A. Douglas prophecy|Stephen A. Douglas prophecy]]
+
|subject=Wilford Woodruff demolished Endowment House?
−
|-
+
|summary=320
−
|
+
}}
−
====407====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Most accurate history in all the world|Most accurate history in all the world]]
+
|link=/Above the law
−
|-
+
|subject=Above the law
−
|
+
|summary=325
−
 
+
}}
−
====408====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
||Hugh Nibley||Personal letter (1966)||[[/Advertising for the Tanners|Advertising for the Tanners]]
+
|link=/Approved marriages 1890-1899
−
|-
+
|subject=Approved marriages 1890-1899
−
|
+
|summary=331
−
====414====
+
}}
−
||Ezra Taft Benson||Conference Report (October 1987)||[[/The LDS as Mindless Followers|The LDS as Mindless Followers]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Vengeance hymns
−
|
+
|subject=Vengeance hymns
−
====418====
+
|summary=334
−
|| || ||[[/President Hinckley and enemies of the Church|President Hinckley and enemies of the Church]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|
+
|link=/Joseph F. Smith finally admits
−
====424====
+
|subject=Joseph F. Smith finally admits
−
|| || ||[[/Church leaders will always know deception|Church leaders will always know deception]]
+
|summary=339
−
|-
+
}}
−
|
+
{{SummaryItem
−
====443 (PB)====
+
|link=/Double standard on race
−
|| || ||[[/Poisoning myth|Poisoning myth]]
+
|subject=Double standard on race
−
|-
+
|summary=355-372
−
|
+
}}
−
====443 (PB)====
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|| || ||[[/Brigham Young on thieves|Brigham Young on thieves]]
+
|link=/Mormon Doctrine and race issues
−
|-
+
|subject=Mormon Doctrine and race issues
−
|
+
|summary=358-360
−
====441 (PB)====
+
}}
−
|| || ||[[/Boyd K. Packer on the truth|Boyd K. Packer on the truth]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Special relationship with Christ
−
|
+
|subject=Special relationship with Christ
−
 
+
|summary=379-380
−
====475====
+
}}
−
||Joseph Smith, Jr.||The Articles of Faith||[[/The Anti-Mormon Articles of Faith|The Anti-Mormon Articles of Faith]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|}
+
|link=/Natural before spiritual
−
 
+
|subject=Natural before spiritual
−
<!-- Commenting out for now
+
|summary=380
−
=Source Analysis, Sorted by Source=
+
}}
−
All page numbers are from One Nation under Gods (New York: Four Walls Eight Windows, 2002)
+
{{SummaryItem
−
 
+
|link=/Orson Pratt condemns the Bible
−
{| valign="top" border="1" style="width:100%; font-size:85%"
+
|subject=Orson Pratt condemns the Bible
−
!width="30%"|Source cited
+
|summary=383-384
−
!width="30%"|Person Cited
+
}}
−
!width="10%"|Page
+
{{SummaryItem
−
!width="30%"|Article
+
|link=/Gordon B. Hinckley Understands Doctrine
−
|-
+
|subject=Gordon B. Hinckley Understands Doctrine
−
| ---||Richard Abanes||53||[[/Seeing the Plates|Seeing the Plates]]
+
|summary=389: Gordon B. Hinckley, General Conference (1997)
−
|-
+
}}
−
|The Articles of Faith||Joseph Smith, Jr.||475||[[/The Anti-Mormon Articles of Faith|The Anti-Mormon Articles of Faith]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Forged Rocky Mountain prophecy
−
|Biographical Sketches of Joseph Smith the Prophet, and His Progenitors for many Generations||Lucy Mack Smith||64||[[/Tall Tales|Tall Tales]]
+
|subject=Forged Rocky Mountain prophecy
−
|-
+
|summary=406
−
|BYU Studies 21:264-265||Boyd K. Packer||xv||[[/Historical Suppression in the Church|Historical Suppression in the Church]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|Conference Report (October 1987)||Ezra Taft Benson||414||[[/The LDS as Mindless Followers|The LDS as Mindless Followers]]
+
|link=/Stephen A. Douglas prophecy
−
|-
+
|subject=Stephen A. Douglas prophecy
−
|Cultures in Conflict||John E. Hallwas and Roger D. Launius||xvi||[[/An Example of Biased Histories|An Example of Biased Histories]]
+
|summary=406
−
|-
+
}}
−
|Dialogue (Winter 1987)||Eugene England||289||[[/LDS "Birth Machines"|LDS "Birth Machines"]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Most accurate history in all the world
−
|Early Mormon Documents||Albert Chandler||95||[[/Those Power-Hungry Mormons|Those Power-Hungry Mormons]]
+
|subject=Most accurate history in all the world
−
|-
+
|summary=407
−
|Early Mormon Documents||Dan Vogel||72||[[/Prophetic Autobiography|Prophetic Autobiography]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|General Conference (1997)||Gordon B. Hinckley||389||[[/Gordon B. Hinckley Understands Doctrine|Gordon B. Hinckley Understands Doctrine]]
+
|link=/Advertising for the Tanners
−
|-
+
|subject=Advertising for the Tanners
−
|History of the Church||Joseph Smith, Jr.||xxi||[[/Destroying Governments and Religions|Destroying Governments and Religions]]
+
|summary=408: Hugh Nibley, Personal letter (1966)
−
|-
+
}}
−
|History of the Church||Joseph Smith, Jr.||171||[[/Joseph Smith's Narcissism|Joseph Smith's Narcissism]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/The LDS as Mindless Followers
−
|History of the Church||Joseph Smith, Jr.||177||[[/Joseph's "Grandiose Sense of Self Importance"|Joseph's "Grandiose Sense of Self Importance"]]
+
|subject=The LDS as Mindless Followers
−
|-
+
|summary=414: Ezra Taft Benson, Conference Report (October 1987)
−
|History of the Church||Joseph Smith, Jr.||178||[[/The Wrestling Prophet|The Wrestling Prophet]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|History of the Church||Joseph Smith, Jr.||179||[[/America's Fighting Prophet|America's Fighting Prophet]]
+
|link=/President Hinckley and enemies of the Church
−
|-
+
|subject=President Hinckley and enemies of the Church
−
|Journal of Discourses 2:310||Brigham Young||222||[[/Brigham and the Kingdom of God|Brigham and the Kingdom of God]]
+
|summary=418
−
|-
+
}}
−
|Journal of Discourses 2:311||Brigham Young||245||[[/Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"|Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Church leaders will always know deception
−
|Journal of Discourses 2:317||Brigham Young||222||[[/Ruling Over the Earth|Ruling Over the Earth]]
+
|subject=Church leaders will always know deception
−
|-
+
|summary=424
−
|Journal of Discourses 4:269||Brigham Young||xxiv||[[/Morally, ethically, spiritually superior|Morally, ethically, spiritually superior?]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|Journal of Discourses 11:249||Brigham Young||xx||[[/Christ Setting up a Theocracy in Missouri|Christ Setting up a Theocracy in Missouri]]
+
|link=/Poisoning myth
−
|-
+
|subject=Poisoning myth
−
|Journal of Discourses 14:205||Brigham Young||220||[[/Brigham, the Dictator|Brigham, the Dictator]]
+
|summary=443 (PB)
−
|-
+
}}
−
|Letter to Martin Cowan||John A. Wilson||55||[[/Reformed Egyptian|Reformed Egyptian]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/Brigham Young on thieves
−
|Letter to Sandra Tanner||Levi Edgar Young||175||[[/Thou Shalt Not Raise a False Report|Thou Shalt Not Raise a False Report]]
+
|subject=Brigham Young on thieves
−
|-
+
|summary=443 (PB)
−
|Personal letter (1857)||Brigham Young||245||[[/Orders to Starve Gentiles|Orders to Starve Gentiles]]
+
}}
−
|-
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|Personal letter (1966)||Hugh Nibley||408||[[/Advertising for the Tanners|Advertising for the Tanners]]
+
|link=Criticism of Mormonism/Books/One Nation Under Gods/Use of sources/Boyd K. Packer on the truth
−
|-
+
|subject=Boyd K. Packer on the truth
−
|Private Eye Weekly||Allen Roberts||xv||[[/Calling All Mormon Scholars|Calling All Mormon Scholars]]
+
|summary=441 (PB)
−
|-
+
}}
−
|Utah Holiday||Fred Esplin||xviii||[[/The Mormon Quest for Power|The Mormon Quest for Power]]
+
{{SummaryItem
−
|-
+
|link=/The Anti-Mormon Articles of Faith
−
|Utah Holiday||Fred Esplin||xx||[[/Perception and Reality|Perception and Reality]]
+
|subject=The Anti-Mormon Articles of Faith
−
|}
+
|summary=475: Joseph Smith, Jr., The Articles of Faith
−
 
+
}}
−
=Source Analysis, Sorted by Person=
 
−
All page numbers are from One Nation under Gods (New York: Four Walls Eight Windows, 2002)
 
−
 
 
−
{| valign="top" border="1" style="width:100%; font-size:85%"
 
−
!width="30%"|Person cited
 
−
!width="30%"|Source Cited
 
−
!width="10%"|Page
 
−
!width="30%"|Article
 
−
|-
 
−
|Abanes, Richard||---||53||[[/Seeing the Plates|Seeing the Plates]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Benson, Ezra Taft||Conference Report (October 1987)||414||[[/The LDS as Mindless Followers|The LDS as Mindless Followers]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Chandler, Albert||Early Mormon Documents||95||[[/Those Power-Hungry Mormons|Those Power-Hungry Mormons]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|England, Eugene||Dialogue (Winter 1987)||289||[[/LDS "Birth Machines"|LDS "Birth Machines"]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Esplin, Fred||Utah Holiday||xviii||[[/The Mormon Quest for Power|The Mormon Quest for Power]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Esplin, Fred||Utah Holiday||xx||[[/Perception and Reality|Perception and Reality]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Hallwas, John E.||Cultures in Conflict||xvi||[[/An Example of Biased Histories|An Example of Biased Histories]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Hinckley, Gordon B.||General Conference (1997)||389||[[/Gordon B. Hinckley Understands Doctrine|Gordon B. Hinckley Understands Doctrine]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Launius, Roger D.||Cultures in Conflict||xvi||[[/An Example of Biased Histories|An Example of Biased Histories]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Nibley, Hugh||Personal letter (1966)||408||[[/Advertising for the Tanners|Advertising for the Tanners]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Packer, Boyd K.||BYU Studies 21:264-265||xv||[[/Historical Suppression in the Church|Historical Suppression in the Church]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Roberts, Allen||Private Eye Weekly||xv||[[/Calling All Mormon Scholars|Calling All Mormon Scholars]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Smith, Joseph Jr.||The Articles of Faith||475||[[/The Anti-Mormon Articles of Faith|The Anti-Mormon Articles of Faith]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Smith, Joseph Jr.||History of the Church||xxi||[[/Destroying Governments and Religions|Destroying Governments and Religions]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Smith, Joseph Jr.||History of the Church||171||[[/Joseph Smith's Narcissism|Joseph Smith's Narcissism]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Smith, Joseph Jr.||History of the Church||177||[[/Joseph's "Grandiose Sense of Self Importance"|Joseph's "Grandiose Sense of Self Importance"]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Smith, Joseph Jr.||History of the Church||178||[[/The Wrestling Prophet|The Wrestling Prophet]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Smith, Joseph Jr.||History of the Church||179||[[/America's Fighting Prophet|America's Fighting Prophet]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Smith, Lucy Mack||Biographical Sketches of Joseph Smith the Prophet, and His Progenitors for many Generations||64||[[/Tall Tales|Tall Tales]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Vogel, Dan||Early Mormon Documents||72||[[/Prophetic Autobiography|Prophetic Autobiography]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Wilson, John A.||Letter to Martin Cowan||55||[[/Reformed Egyptian|Reformed Egyptian]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Young, Brigham||Journal of Discourses 2:310||222||[[/Brigham and the Kingdom of God|Brigham and the Kingdom of God]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Young, Brigham||Journal of Discourses 2:311||245||[[/Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"|Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Young, Brigham||Journal of Discourses 2:317||222||[[/Ruling Over the Earth|Ruling Over the Earth]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Brigham Young||Journal of Discourses 4:269||xxiv||[[/Morally, ethically, spiritually superior|Morally, ethically, spiritually superior?]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Young, Brigham||Journal of Discourses 11:249||xx||[[/Christ Setting up a Theocracy in Missouri|Christ Setting up a Theocracy in Missouri]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Young, Brigham||Journal of Discourses 14:205||220||[[/Brigham, the Dictator|Brigham, the Dictator]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Young, Brigham||Personal letter (1857)||245||[[/Orders to Starve Gentiles|Orders to Starve Gentiles]]
 
−
|-
 
−
|Young, Levi Edgar||Letter to Sandra Tanner||175||[[/Thou Shalt Not Raise a False Report|Thou Shalt Not Raise a False Report]]
 
−
|}
 
−
-->
 
−
 
 
−
=Further reading=
 
−
{{FAIRAnalysisWiki}}
 
−
 
 
−
[[fr:Specific works/One Nation Under Gods/Use of sources]]
 

Latest revision as of 14:15, 13 April 2024

Contents

One Nation Under Gods: Source Analysis, Sorted by Page Number



Index of Claims
A FAIR Analysis of: One Nation Under Gods, a work by author: Richard Abanes
 		Loaded and prejudicial language

All page numbers are currently from the paperback edition of One Nation under Gods (New York: Four Walls Eight Windows, 2002), except where noted.

Dallin H. Oaks on God

Summary: One critic of Mormonism claims that Dallin Oaks told Mormons in 1995 "that so-called Christianity sees God as an entirely different kind of being."

Historical Suppression in the Church

Summary: xv (HB): Boyd K. Packer, BYU Studies 21:264-265

Calling All Mormon Scholars

Summary: xv (HB): Allen Roberts, Private Eye Weekly

An Example of Biased Histories

Summary: xvi (HB): John E. Hallwas and Roger D. Launius, Cultures in Conflict

The Mormon Quest for Power

Summary: xviii (HB): Fred Esplin, Utah Holiday

Perception and Reality

Summary: xx (HB): Fred Esplin, Utah Holiday

Christ Setting up a Theocracy in Missouri

Summary: xx (HB): Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 11:249

Destroying Governments and Religions

Summary: xxi (HB): Joseph Smith, Jr., History of the Church

Morally, ethically, spiritually superior?

Summary: xxiv (HB): Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses

"This is My Beloved Son"

Summary: 16: Richard Abanes

Lucy and the angel

Summary: 27: Lucy Mack Smith, "Preliminary Manuscript" of Biographical Sketches of Joseph Smith the Prophet, and His Progenitors for many Generations

Seeing the Plates

Summary: 53, Richard Abanes

Reformed Egyptian

Summary: 55, John A. Wilson, Letter to Martin Cowan

Tall Tales

Summary: 64, Lucy Mack Smith, Biographical Sketches of Joseph Smith the Prophet, and His Progenitors for many Generations

Prophetic Autobiography

Summary: 72, Dan Vogel, Early Mormon Documents

No Book of Mormon archaeology

Summary: 75, Dee F. Green, "Book of Mormon Archeology: the Myths and the Alternatives," Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought

Christianity is satanic

Summary: 86, Brigham Young, John Taylor, Journal of Discourses

Divining rods to Kimball and Young

Summary: 89

Those Power-Hungry Mormons

Summary: 95: Albert Chandler, Early Mormon Documents

Distorted account of three degrees of glory

Summary: 103n2

Haranguing non-Mormons

Summary: 105

Missouri belongs to the Mormons

Summary: 110

Disobey secular law

Summary: 116

Redeemed by September 1836

Summary: 122: Joseph Smith, History of the Church

Joseph gave couples marriage certificates

Summary: 129

Joseph owned 144 acres in Kirtland

Summary: 135

Warren Parrish and Kirtland Safety Society "revelation"

Summary: 136

Joseph Smith's Narcissism

Summary: 171: Joseph Smith, Jr., History of the Church

Brigham Young said that Joseph on par with Jesus Christ?

Summary: 174: Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses

Thou Shalt Not Raise a False Report

Summary: 175: Levi Edgar Young, Letter to Sandra Tanner

Joseph's "Grandiose Sense of Self Importance"

Summary: 177, Joseph Smith, Jr., History of the Church

The Wrestling Prophet

Summary: 178: Joseph Smith, Jr., History of the Church

America's Fighting Prophet

Summary: 179: Joseph Smith, Jr., History of the Church

Joseph hit a baptist preacher

Summary: 179

D and C 98 justifies murder

Summary: 191

Rockwell admitting to shooting Boggs

Summary: 192

Debauchery and despotism at Nauvoo

Summary: 196: History of the Church

Nauvoo police violence

Summary: 212

Killing Lambert Symes

Summary: 213

Irvine Hodge murder

Summary: 213

Other homicides by members of the Council of Fifty

Summary: 213

Flogging those out of fellowship

Summary: 213-214

Whistling and Whittling Brigades

Summary: 214

Counterfeiting apostles and Joseph

Summary: 216-217

Brigham, the Dictator

Summary: 220: Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 14:205

Gentiles have no right to property

Summary: 221-222

Brigham and the Kingdom of God

Summary: 222: Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 2:310

Ruling Over the Earth

Summary: 222: Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 2:317

Ettie V. Smith

Summary: 223

Brigham as President of the United States

Summary: 223

Church and state all one now

Summary: 223

Heber C. Kimball--violence and intimidation

Summary: 223

Early federal territorial officials

Summary: 227-228

Cutting off from the earth

Summary: 233

Murder unfaithful Mormons to save souls

Summary: 234-235

Apostles killed Judas

Summary: 235

Brigham and bowie knife

Summary: 236 (PB only)

Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"

Summary: 236-237: Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 2:311

Orders to Starve Gentiles

Summary: 245: Brigham Young, Personal letter (1857)

Brigham Young ordered Mountain Meadows Massacre

Summary: 245

Brigham Young orders MMM monument demolished

Summary: 251

Blood atone Washington politicians

Summary: 260

Saints sole rulers over every government

Summary: 266

Attitude of Saints to Civil War prophecy

Summary: 270

Hyde on US to be divided

Summary: 270

Beating John W. Dawson

Summary: 271

Too much education damaging

Summary: 271

Conception of Christ

Summary: 287

LDS "Birth Machines"

Summary: 289: Eugene England, Dialogue (Winter 1987)

Wife swapping

Summary: 295

Damned without plural marriage

Summary: 301

John Taylor September 1886 revelation

Summary: 316

Polygamy absolutely essential to godhood

Summary: 317

Wilford Woodruff demolished Endowment House?

Summary: 320

Above the law

Summary: 325

Approved marriages 1890-1899

Summary: 331

Vengeance hymns

Summary: 334

Joseph F. Smith finally admits

Summary: 339

Double standard on race

Summary: 355-372

Mormon Doctrine and race issues

Summary: 358-360

Special relationship with Christ

Summary: 379-380

Natural before spiritual

Summary: 380

Orson Pratt condemns the Bible

Summary: 383-384

Gordon B. Hinckley Understands Doctrine

Summary: 389: Gordon B. Hinckley, General Conference (1997)

Forged Rocky Mountain prophecy

Summary: 406

Stephen A. Douglas prophecy

Summary: 406

Most accurate history in all the world

Summary: 407

Advertising for the Tanners

Summary: 408: Hugh Nibley, Personal letter (1966)

The LDS as Mindless Followers

Summary: 414: Ezra Taft Benson, Conference Report (October 1987)

President Hinckley and enemies of the Church

Summary: 418

Church leaders will always know deception

Summary: 424

Poisoning myth

Summary: 443 (PB)

Brigham Young on thieves

Summary: 443 (PB)

Boyd K. Packer on the truth

Summary: 441 (PB)

The Anti-Mormon Articles of Faith

Summary: 475: Joseph Smith, Jr., The Articles of Faith
Retrieved from "https://www.fairlatterdaysaints.org/answers/index.php?title=Criticism_of_Mormonism/Books/One_Nation_Under_Gods/Use_of_sources&oldid=236918"