FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Array
Criticism of Mormonism/Criticism of "17 Points of the True Church": Difference between revisions
m (→Answer) |
m (→Question) |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
==Question== | ==Question== | ||
'''''Someone wrote the FAIR Ask the Apologist service saying:''''' | |||
My testimony is in no way based on the "17 Points," and I feel that it is overused and overemphasized within the Church, but regardless, I would like to know about the information claiming that his story his false. | :"My question is about that fellow who wrote the "17 Points of the True Church" and the validity of his story. I stumbled into a web site that talked about a particular fireside this man gave where someone approached him on the truth of his story. Afterwards the man was told by a stake president that he must confess that he lied because he had been essentially "found out," and that many details of his story were fabricated. | ||
:My testimony is in no way based on the "17 Points," and I feel that it is overused and overemphasized within the Church, but regardless, I would like to know about the information claiming that his story his false." | |||
==Answer== | ==Answer== | ||
Revision as of 02:57, 28 June 2009
This page is based on an answer to a question submitted to the FAIR web site, or a frequently asked question.
Question
Someone wrote the FAIR Ask the Apologist service saying:
- "My question is about that fellow who wrote the "17 Points of the True Church" and the validity of his story. I stumbled into a web site that talked about a particular fireside this man gave where someone approached him on the truth of his story. Afterwards the man was told by a stake president that he must confess that he lied because he had been essentially "found out," and that many details of his story were fabricated.
- My testimony is in no way based on the "17 Points," and I feel that it is overused and overemphasized within the Church, but regardless, I would like to know about the information claiming that his story his false."
Answer
The person responsible for the "17 Points of the True Church" is a man named Floyd Weston.
An ex-Mormon critic of the Church has claimed that Weston fabricated the details of how the "17 Points" were created. For example, Weston claims to have developed the list when he was a student at Cal Tech, and that during this time Albert Einstein visited the school. The critic has charged that Weston was actually at Cal Tech several years too late to see Einstein's visit. All of this is based on an email to the critic from an anonymous person who claims to know someone who knew Weston. So, the source is anonymous and almost impossible to verify. Anyone with further verifiable information is invited to contact FAIR.
What this has to do with the validity of Weston's "17 Points" is not entirely clear, but it seems that the critic is attempting to discredit Weston's list (and, by implication, the Church) by discrediting Weston himself. This would be a form of the ad hominem fallacy.
Conclusion
It makes little difference for the Church if Weston made up his story. (Though lying to defend the Church is not excusable.) The truth or falsity of Weston's personal history has no bearing whatsoever on the truth of the restored gospel.
Additionally, the "17 Points" may be used by certain individual members of the Church, but they have not been used in any official Church publications or adopted by the Church in any other way. The claims of the restored gospel stand independent of Weston's list.
Further reading
External links
- The 17 Points of the True Church (herrons.com). off-site (link moved)