FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Difference between revisions of "Mormonism and Wikipedia/Martin Harris"
(→: typo) |
(→: link) |
||
| Line 433: | Line 433: | ||
*Martin Harris interview with David B. Dille, 15 September 1853 in ''EMD'' 2: 296-97. | *Martin Harris interview with David B. Dille, 15 September 1853 in ''EMD'' 2: 296-97. | ||
|response= | |response= | ||
| − | *{{WikipediaCITE}}The sentence as it is structured in Wikipedia is disingenuous. The cited source says nothing about the weight of the plates, and the wiki editor conflates the event during which Martin held the plates on his knee with Martin's later encounter with the plates as a witness. The wiki editor has taken the statement about Harris holding the plates on his knee for an hour and a half and attempted to use this for the purpose of implying that the plates would have been too heavy had Harris been telling the truth. It is also not made clear that the handling of the plates occurred during Martin's experience as one of the Three Witnesses. | + | *{{WikipediaCITE|editor=John Foxe|wikipedialink=http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Martin_Harris_(Latter_Day_Saints)&diff=96180666&oldid=96179363}}The sentence as it is structured in Wikipedia is disingenuous. The cited source says nothing about the weight of the plates, and the wiki editor conflates the event during which Martin held the plates on his knee with Martin's later encounter with the plates as a witness. The wiki editor has taken the statement about Harris holding the plates on his knee for an hour and a half and attempted to use this for the purpose of implying that the plates would have been too heavy had Harris been telling the truth. It is also not made clear that the handling of the plates occurred during Martin's experience as one of the Three Witnesses. Note the editor's edit summary: "addition of some non-faith promoting material." |
*From the cited source (''Early Mormon Documents'' 2:297): | *From the cited source (''Early Mormon Documents'' 2:297): | ||
<blockquote> | <blockquote> | ||
I was the right-hand man of Joseph Smith, and I know that he was a Prophet of God. I know the Book of Mormon is true...''And you know that I know that it is true.'' I know that the plates have been translated by the gift and power of God, for his voice declared it unto us; therefore I know of a surety that the work is true. For...did I not at one time hold the plates on my knee an hour-and-a-half, whilst in conversation with Joseph, when we went to bury them in the woods, that the enemy might not obtain them? Yes, I did. And as many of the plates as Joseph Smith translated I handled with my hands, plate after plate." | I was the right-hand man of Joseph Smith, and I know that he was a Prophet of God. I know the Book of Mormon is true...''And you know that I know that it is true.'' I know that the plates have been translated by the gift and power of God, for his voice declared it unto us; therefore I know of a surety that the work is true. For...did I not at one time hold the plates on my knee an hour-and-a-half, whilst in conversation with Joseph, when we went to bury them in the woods, that the enemy might not obtain them? Yes, I did. And as many of the plates as Joseph Smith translated I handled with my hands, plate after plate." | ||
</blockquote> | </blockquote> | ||
| − | }} | + | }} |
===== ===== | ===== ===== | ||
Revision as of 20:31, 19 January 2011
| A FairMormon Analysis of Wikipedia: Martin Harris (Latter Day Saints) A work by a collaboration of authors (Link to Wikipedia article here)
|
| The name Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.. Wikipedia content is copied and made available under the GNU Free Documentation License. |
| High Level Summary | |
|---|---|
| Title | Wikipedia article "Martin Harris" |
| Type | Website |
| Author(s) | Controlling editors TBD |
| Affiliation | TBD |
| Accuracy | Negative aspects emphasized and given undue weight and position within the article, with positive aspects subdued, relegated to footnotes, or omitted. |
| Temple content | None |
An analysis of the Wikipedia article "Martin Harris (Latter Day Saints)"
Updated 1/18/2011
From the Wikipedia article:
Martin Harris (May 18, 1783 – July 10, 1875) underwrote the first printing of The Book of Mormon and also served as one of Three Witnesses who testified that they had seen the Golden Plates from which Joseph Smith said the Book of Mormon had been translated.
FAIR's analysis:
Early life
From the Wikipedia article:
Martin Harris was born in Eastown, New York, the second of the eight children. According to historian Ronald W. Walker, little is known of his youth, "but if his later personality and activity are guides, the boy partook of the sturdy values of his neighborhood which included work, honesty, rudimentary education, and godly fear."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Walker (1986) , p. 31
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
In 1808, Harris married his cousin Lucy Harris.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Until 1831, Harris lived in Palmyra, New York, where he was a prosperous farmer. Harris's neighbors considered him both an honest and superstitious man.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- More "than a dozen of Harris's Palmyra contemporaries left descriptions of the man that describe his honor, honesty, industry, peacefulness, and respectability, his hard-headed Yankee shrewdness and his wealth." Walker (1986) , p. 35
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
A biographer wrote that Harris's "imagination was excitable and fecund." For example, Harris once imagined that a sputtering candle was the work of the devil.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- "Once while reading scripture, he reportedly mistook a candle's sputtering as a sign that the devil desired him to stop. Another time he excitedly awoke from his sleep believing that a creature as large as a dog had been upon his chest, though a nearby associate could find nothing to confirm his fears. Several hostile and perhaps unreliable accounts told of visionary experiences with Satan and Christ, Harris once reporting that Christ had been poised on a roof beam." Walker (1986) , pp. 34–35
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
An acquaintance said that Harris claimed to have seen Jesus in the shape of a deer and walked and talked with him for two or three miles.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- John A. Clark letter, August 31, 1840 in EMD, 2: 271: "No matter where he went, he saw visions and supernatural appearances all around him. He told a gentleman in Palmyra, after one of his excursions to Pennsylvania, while the translation of the Book of Mormon was going on, that on the way he met the Lord Jesus Christ, who walked along by the side of him in the shape of a deer for two or three miles, talking with him as familiarly as one man talks with another." According to two Ohio newspapers, shortly after Harris arrived in Kirtland he began claiming to have "seen Jesus Christ and that he is the handsomest man he ever did see. He has also seen the Devil, whom he described as a very sleek haired fellow with four feet, and a head like that of a Jack-ass." Vogel,EMD 2: 271, note 32.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
The local Presbyterian minister called him "a visionary fanatic."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Walker (1986) , p. 34-35
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
A friend, who praised Harris as being "universally esteemed as an honest man," also declared that Harris's mind "was overbalanced by 'marvellousness'" and that his belief in earthly visitations of angels and ghosts gave him the local reputation of being crazy.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Pomroy Tucker Reminiscence, 1858 in Early Mormon Documents 3: 71.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Another friend said, "Martin was a man that would do just as he agreed with you. But, he was a great man for seeing spooks."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Lorenzo Saunders Interview, November 12, 1884, Early Mormon Documents 2: 149.
FAIR's analysis:
Book of Mormon witness
From the Wikipedia article:
In 1828, Joseph Smith, Jr., another resident of Palmyra, said he had obtained a record of ancient inhabitants of the Americas engraved on golden plates and that he had been directed by the angel Moroni to translate this work. Harris assisted Smith both financially and by serving as his scribe. Mormon tradition holds that through the use of Urim and Thummim and/or a seer stone, Smith saw a translation of the writing on the plates and dictated the words to Harris.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- No source provided
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Because Harris desired assurance of the work's authenticity, Smith transcribed characters from the plates to a piece of paper, perhaps the one now known as the Anthon transcript. Harris took this document to New York City, where he met with Charles Anthon, a professor of linguistics at Columbia College. Although Harris and Anthon later told conflicting versions about their encounter, the episode apparently satisfied Harris's doubts about the authenticity of the Golden Plates.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- See EMD 4: 377-86.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Nevertheless, Harris's wife continued to oppose his collaboration with Smith. After translating the first 116 pages of the manuscript, Harris asked Smith for permission to take the manuscript back to his wife in order to convince her of its authenticity. Smith reluctantly agreed. After Harris had shown the pages to Lucy and some others, the manuscript disappeared.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Doctrine and Covenants 3
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
The loss temporarily halted the translation of the plates, and when Smith began again, he used other scribes, primarily Oliver Cowdery. Nevertheless, Harris continued to support Smith financially, and as the translation neared completion, Smith revealed that three men would be called as "special witnesses" to the existence of the Golden Plates. Harris, along with Cowdery and David Whitmer, was one of these Three Witnesses, although Joseph Smith clearly indicated that Harris's experience occurred separately from that of Whitmer and Cowdery.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Joseph Smith-History, 1839.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Harris's attestation above what was implied to have been a joint testimony was printed with the book, and it has been included in nearly every subsequent edition.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- No source provided
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
In part due to their continued disagreement over the legitimacy of Joseph Smith and the golden plates, and because of the loss of his farm, which he had mortgaged to publish the Book of Mormon,
Wikipedia footnotes:
- In March 2007, Russell Martin Harris, great-great-grandson of Martin Harris, gave a leather wallet, said to have been the one that carried Harris's money to the printer, to the LDS Church so that the wallet could be displayed at the Museum of Church History and Art in Salt Lake City. AP story.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Harris and his wife separated. Lucy Harris was described by Lucy Mack Smith as a woman of "irascible temper," but Harris may also have abused her. Lucy Harris also suggested that her husband may have committed adultery with a neighboring "Mrs. Haggart."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Lucy Mack Smith, 1853, in EMD 1: 367; "Lucy Harris statement," in EMD, 2: 34-36: "In one of his fits of rage he struck me with the butt end of a whip, which I think had been used for driving oxen, and was about the size of my thumb, and three or four feet long. He beat me on the head four or five times, and the next day turned me out of doors twice, and beat me in a shameful manner....Whether the Mormon religion be true or false, I leave the world to judge, for its effects upon Martin Harris have been to make hi more cross, turbulent and abusive to me." In March 1830, a revelation from Smith warned Harris not to "covet thy neighbor's wife." D&C 19: 25.
FAIR's analysis:
LDS High Priest
From the Wikipedia article:
Harris became an early member of the Church of Christ, which Joseph Smith organized on April 6, 1830. On June 3, 1831, at a conference at the headquarters of the church in Kirtland, Ohio, Harris was ordained to the office of High Priest and served as a missionary in the Midwest, Pennsylvania, and New York.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
On February 17, 1834, Harris was ordained a member of Kirtland High Council, which was then the chief judicial and legislative council of the church. In response to the conflicts between Mormons and non-Mormons in Missouri, Harris joined what is now known as Zion's Camp and marched fruitlessly from Kirtland to Clay County, Missouri. Afterwards, Harris — along with Oliver Cowdery and David Whitmer — ordained a "traveling High Council" of twelve men that eventually became the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Joseph Smith, B.H. Roberts (ed.), (1902) History of the Church, 2:186-87.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
(Some early church leaders claimed that Harris, like Joseph Smith, Jr. and Oliver Cowdery, was ordained to the priesthood office of apostle;
Wikipedia footnotes:
- See, e.g., Heber C. Kimball, Journal of Discourses 6:29.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
however, there is no record of this ordination, and Harris—as with Cowdery—was never a member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles.)
Wikipedia footnotes:
- No source provided
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Lucy Harris died in the summer of 1836, and on November 1, 1836, Harris married Caroline Young, the 22-year-old daughter of Brigham Young's brother, John. Although he was thirty-one years older than his new wife, Harris and Caroline had seven children together.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
In 1837, dissension arose in Kirtland over the failure of the church's Kirtland Safety Society bank. Harris called it a "fraud" and was among the dissenters who broke with Smith and attempted to reorganize the church. Led by Warren Parrish, the reformers excommunicated Smith and Sidney Rigdon, who relocated to Far West, Missouri.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- In 1838, Joseph Smith called the Three Witnesses Cowdery, Harris, and Whitmer "too mean to mention; and we had liked to have forgotten them." B.H. Roberts, ed. History of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (Salt Lake City: Deseret News, 1905), 3: 232.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Parrish's church in Kirtland took control of the temple and became known as The Church of Christ. In its 1838 articles of incorporation, Harris was named one of the church's three trustees. By 1839, Parrish and other church leaders had rejected the Book of Mormon and consequently broke with Harris, who continued to testify to its truth. By 1840, Harris returned to communion with Smith's church, which had subsequently relocated to Nauvoo, Illinois.
FAIR's analysis:
Strangite, Whitmerite, Gladdenite, Williamite, Shaker
From the Wikipedia article:
Even before he had become a Mormon, Harris had changed his religion at least five times.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Harris had been a Quaker, a Universalist, a Restorationist, a Baptist, a Presbyterian, and perhaps a Methodist. Walker (1986) , pp. 30–33
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
After Smith's death, Harris continued this earlier pattern, remaining in Kirtland and accepting James J. Strang as Mormonism's new prophet, a prophet with his own set of supernatural plates and witnesses to authenticate them.
Wikipedia footnotes:
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
By 1847, Harris had broken with Strang and accepted the leadership claims of fellow Book of Mormon witness, David Whitmer. Mormon Apostle William E. M'Lellin organized a Whitmerite congregation in Kirtland, and Harris became a member. By 1851, Harris accepted another Latter Day Saint factional leader, Gladden Bishop, as prophet and joined Bishop's Kirtland-based organization.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Walker (1986) , pp. 29–30
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
In 1855, Harris joined with the last surviving brother of Joseph Smith, William Smith and declared that William was Joseph's true successor. Harris was also briefly intrigued by the "Roll and Book," a supernatural scripture delivered to the Shakers.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- A pro-Mormon defense of Harris's behavior with regard to the Shakers. Harris never actually joined the Shakers; they advocated celibacy, and Harris was married. But Phineas H. Young told Brigham Young that Harris' testimony of Shakerism was "greater than it was of the Book of Mormon." Letter of Phineas H. Young to Brigham Young, Dec. 31, 1844.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
By the 1860s, all of these organizations had either dissolved or declined. In 1856, his wife Caroline left him to gather with the Mormons in Utah while he remained in Kirtland and gave tours of the temple to curious visitors.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- EMD, 2: 258.
FAIR's analysis:
Rebaptism into the LDS faith
From the Wikipedia article:
In 1870, at age 87, Harris moved to the Utah Territory and shortly thereafter was rebaptized into The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church). Harris, who had been left destitute and without a congregation in Kirtland, accepted the assistance of members of the LDS Church, who raised $200 to help him move west to Utah. Harris lived the last four and a half years of his life with relatives in Cache Valley. He died on June 10, 1875 in Clarkston, Utah and was buried there. A pageant about Harris called "Martin Harris, The Man Who Knew", sponsored by LDS Church, is performed every other year in August in Clarkston.
Wikipedia footnotes:
FAIR's analysis:
Testimony to the Book of Mormon
From the Wikipedia article:
Although he was estranged from the LDS Church for most of his life, Harris continued to testify to the truth of the Book of Mormon. Nevertheless, at least during the early years, Harris "seems to have repeatedly admitted the internal, subjective nature of his visionary experience."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Vogel, EMD, 2: 255.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
The foreman in the Palmyra printing office that produced the first Book of Mormon said that Harris "used to practice a good deal of his characteristic jargon and 'seeing with the spiritual eye,' and the like."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Pomeroy Tucker, Origin, Rise, and Progress of Mormonism (New York: D. Appleton and Co., 1867), 71 in EMD, 3: 122.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
John H. Gilbert, the typesetter for most of the book, said that he had asked Harris, "Martin, did you see those plates with your naked eyes?" According to Gilbert, Harris "looked down for an instant, raised his eyes up, and said, 'No, I saw them with a spiritual eye."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- John H. Gilbert, "Memorandum," 8 September 1892, in EMD, 2: 548.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Two other Palmyra residents said that Harris told them that he had seen the plates with "the eye of faith" or "spiritual eyes."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Martin Harris interviews with John A. Clark, 1827 & 1828 in EMD, 2: 270; Jesse Townsend to Phineas Stiles, 24 December 1833, in EMD, 3: 22.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
In 1838, Harris is said to have told an Ohio congregation that "he never saw the plates with his natural eyes, only in vision or imagination."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Stephen Burnett to Lyman E. Johnson, 15 April 1838 in EMD, 2: 291.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
A neighbor of Harris in Kirtland, Ohio, said that Harris "never claimed to have seen [the plates] with his natural eyes, only spiritual vision."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Reuben P. Harmon statement, c. 1885, in EMD, 2: 385.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
In March 1838, disillusioned church members said that Harris had publicly denied that neither he nor the other Witnesses to the Book of Mormon had ever seen or handled the golden plates—although he had not been present when Whitmer and Cowdery first claimed to have viewed them—and they claimed that Harris's recantation, made during a period of crisis in early Mormonism, induced five influential members, including three Apostles, to leave the Church.
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Stephen Burnett to Luke S. Johnson, 15 April 1838, in Joseph Smith's Letterbook, Early Mormon Documents 2: 290-92.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Even at the end of his long life, Harris said that he had seen the plates in "a state of entrancement."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Metcalf in EMD, 2: 347.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Nevertheless, in 1853, Harris told one David Dille that he had held the forty- to sixty-pound plates on his knee for "an hour-and-a-half" and handled the plates with his hands, "plate after plate."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Martin Harris interview with David B. Dille, 15 September 1853 in EMD 2: 296-97.
FAIR's analysis:
From the Wikipedia article:
Even later, Harris affirmed that he had seen the plates and the angel with his natural eyes: "Gentlemen," holding out his hand, "do you see that hand? Are you sure you see it? Or are your eyes playing you a trick or something? No. Well, as sure as you see my hand so sure did I see the Angel and the plates."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Martin Harris interview with Robert Barter, c. 1870 in EMD, 2: 390.
FAIR's analysis:
}}
From the Wikipedia article:
The following year Harris affirmed that "No man heard me in any way deny the truth of the Book of Mormon [or] the administration of the angel that showed me the plates."
Wikipedia footnotes:
- Letter of Martin Harris, Sr., to Hanna B. Emerson, January 1871, Smithfield, Utah Territory, Saints' Herald 22 (15 October 1875):630, in EMD 2: 338. See also Richard Lloyd Anderson, Investigating the Book of Mormon Witnesses (Salt Lake City: Deseret Book Company, 1981), 118.
FAIR's analysis:
Citations
- Walker, Ronald W., (1986), Martin Harris: Mormonism's Early Convert off-site .
Further reading
- Richard L. Anderson, Investigating the Book of Mormon Witnesses, (Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 1989).
- Susan Easton Black, Who's Who in the Doctrine & Covenants (1997) ISBN 1-57008-292-8
- Nathan Harris and Rhoda Lapham Family, parents of Martin Harris, annotated genealogy.
- William O. Lewis III, "Martin Harris," on Grampa Bill's G.A. Pages
- H. Michael Marquardt, (Fall 2002), "Martin Harris: The Kirtland Years, 1831-1870", Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought
- Dallin H. Oaks, "The Witness: Martin Harris"
- Edward Stevenson, (1882), "One of the Three Witnesses: Incidents in the Life of Martin Harris,", The Latter Day Saints' Millennial Star, 78–79, 86–87
- Ron Romig, Martin Harris's Kirtland (John Whitmer Books, 2007) ISBN 1934901040
- Dan Vogel, "Introduction to Martin Harris Collection," in Early Mormon Documents (Salt Lake City: Signature Books, 1998), 2: 253-59.
Y