FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Difference between revisions of "Mormon urban legends or folklore"
MikeParker (talk | contribs) (→Response: Fix quotation marks) |
MikeParker (talk | contribs) (Paul Allen's editorial on the "Mormons") |
||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
==Frank Graham and LDS hurricane relief== | ==Frank Graham and LDS hurricane relief== | ||
| − | = | + | <font size="+1">Claim</font> |
| + | |||
The following email began circulating in late September 2005, following the destruction caused by Hurricane Katrina: | The following email began circulating in late September 2005, following the destruction caused by Hurricane Katrina: | ||
| Line 17: | Line 18: | ||
:He stated (that)..."those people are truly a charity driven people. In the scriptures, charity is defined as the pure love of Christ." He went on to remark how the members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints have adopted individuals and families in the Astrodome and are helping them to find missing members of their families. They are keeping touch with their designated person or family on a daily basis, making sure the children are enrolled in and can get to school, taking them to Wal-mart and other retailers to purchase clothing and other necessities, and are taking people to job fairs and interviews to assist them in gaining employment. He stated that he has never seen such a love for complete strangers. This has even brought inactive members, according to Graham, "...out of their homes and back to the church because they want to help and they know that the church will be there, organizing and moving to assist those who have nothing, to remember that they truly are something." | :He stated (that)..."those people are truly a charity driven people. In the scriptures, charity is defined as the pure love of Christ." He went on to remark how the members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints have adopted individuals and families in the Astrodome and are helping them to find missing members of their families. They are keeping touch with their designated person or family on a daily basis, making sure the children are enrolled in and can get to school, taking them to Wal-mart and other retailers to purchase clothing and other necessities, and are taking people to job fairs and interviews to assist them in gaining employment. He stated that he has never seen such a love for complete strangers. This has even brought inactive members, according to Graham, "...out of their homes and back to the church because they want to help and they know that the church will be there, organizing and moving to assist those who have nothing, to remember that they truly are something." | ||
| − | :He ended with a personal opinion that anyone in the Houston area who is an evacuee from New Orleans, who says they haven't been "taken care of" or "seen after", has only themselves to blame for refusing the assistance of the amazing LDS population who are volunteering without so much as asking for anything in return for their efforts." | + | :He ended with a personal opinion that anyone in the Houston area who is an evacuee from New Orleans, who says they haven't been "taken care of" or "seen after", has only themselves to blame for refusing the assistance of the amazing LDS population who are volunteering without so much as |
| + | asking for anything in return for their efforts." | ||
| + | |||
| + | <font size="+1">Response</font> | ||
| − | |||
A Lexis-Nexis check of the Reverend Graham's comments on ''Good Morning America'' shows that he made no such comments.<!-- LINK DOESN'T WORK | A Lexis-Nexis check of the Reverend Graham's comments on ''Good Morning America'' shows that he made no such comments.<!-- LINK DOESN'T WORK | ||
:[http://www6.lexisnexis.com/publisher/EndUser?Action=UserDisplayFullDocument&orgId=574&topicId=100007216&docId=l:311345715&start=14 Transcript of ''Good Morning America'' interview with Frank Graham, 16 September 2005]--> | :[http://www6.lexisnexis.com/publisher/EndUser?Action=UserDisplayFullDocument&orgId=574&topicId=100007216&docId=l:311345715&start=14 Transcript of ''Good Morning America'' interview with Frank Graham, 16 September 2005]--> | ||
| Line 41: | Line 44: | ||
==Prophecy of a Catholic Priest== | ==Prophecy of a Catholic Priest== | ||
| − | = | + | <font size="+1">Claim</font> |
A persistent rumor claims that Lutus Gratus, a Catholic priest, wrote the following in 1739 in his book ''Hope of Zion'', which was purportedly discovered in the library in Bayd, Switzerland: | A persistent rumor claims that Lutus Gratus, a Catholic priest, wrote the following in 1739 in his book ''Hope of Zion'', which was purportedly discovered in the library in Bayd, Switzerland: | ||
| Line 47: | Line 50: | ||
:The old, true Gospel and its truths thereat are lost. False doctrine prevail in all churches on the face of the earth today. All we can do is exhort the people to be just, fear God, shun evil, and pray. Prayer and purity may cause an angel to visit a deep distressed soul, but I will tell you—God will have spoken within a hundred years. He will restore the old Church again. I see a little band of people led by a prophet and persecuted, burnt out and murdered. But in a valley that lies on the shore of a great lake, they will build a city and make a beautiful land, have a temple of magnificent splendor and also possess the old priesthood with teachers, deacons, etc. From every nation shall the true believers be gathered by speedy messengers, and then shall the almighty God speak to the disobedient nation, with thunder, lightning and destructions such as man has never known." | :The old, true Gospel and its truths thereat are lost. False doctrine prevail in all churches on the face of the earth today. All we can do is exhort the people to be just, fear God, shun evil, and pray. Prayer and purity may cause an angel to visit a deep distressed soul, but I will tell you—God will have spoken within a hundred years. He will restore the old Church again. I see a little band of people led by a prophet and persecuted, burnt out and murdered. But in a valley that lies on the shore of a great lake, they will build a city and make a beautiful land, have a temple of magnificent splendor and also possess the old priesthood with teachers, deacons, etc. From every nation shall the true believers be gathered by speedy messengers, and then shall the almighty God speak to the disobedient nation, with thunder, lightning and destructions such as man has never known." | ||
| − | = | + | <font size="+1">Response</font> |
This "prophecy" first appeared in LDS periodicals in both English and German in 1893, in a story by a returned missionary named Jacob Spori. One of the first to question the authenticity of the document was Rulon S. Wells of the First Council of Seventy, who unsuccessfully attempted to locate the book and its contents in Basel a few years after the story surfaced. Other leaders and missionaries also were unable to verify the statement. | This "prophecy" first appeared in LDS periodicals in both English and German in 1893, in a story by a returned missionary named Jacob Spori. One of the first to question the authenticity of the document was Rulon S. Wells of the First Council of Seventy, who unsuccessfully attempted to locate the book and its contents in Basel a few years after the story surfaced. Other leaders and missionaries also were unable to verify the statement. | ||
| Line 54: | Line 57: | ||
*Paul B. Pixton, [http://contentdm.lib.byu.edu/cgi-bin/docviewer.exe?CISOROOT=/byustudies&CISOPTR=21961&CISOSHOW=7292 "'Play it Again, Sam': The Remarkable 'Prophecy' of Samuel Lutz, Alias Christophilus Gratianus, Reconsidered"], ''BYU Studies'' 25/3 (Summer 1985), pp. 27–46. | *Paul B. Pixton, [http://contentdm.lib.byu.edu/cgi-bin/docviewer.exe?CISOROOT=/byustudies&CISOPTR=21961&CISOSHOW=7292 "'Play it Again, Sam': The Remarkable 'Prophecy' of Samuel Lutz, Alias Christophilus Gratianus, Reconsidered"], ''BYU Studies'' 25/3 (Summer 1985), pp. 27–46. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Paul Allen's editorial on the "Mormons"== | ||
| + | |||
| + | <font size="+1">Claim</font> | ||
| + | |||
| + | Paul Allen — co-founder of Microsoft and owner of the Seattle Seahawks and Portland Trail Blazers — wrote a letter praising Mormons that was published in a Santa Clarita, California newspaper. | ||
| + | |||
| + | (One example of this widely-circulated letter can be read in [http://groups.google.com/group/alt.religion.mormon/browse_thread/thread/f4e5c2a957ae2c7a/6631682409ddecbd?lnk=strnum=1&hl=en#6631682409ddecbd this Usenet post].) | ||
| + | |||
| + | <font size="+1">Response</font> | ||
| + | |||
| + | A FAIR volunteer contacted ''[http://www.the-signal.com/ The Signal]'', Santa Clarita Valley's newspaper, and enquired about this. The general manager of the paper confirmed that a letter to the editor from a Paul Allen was published in the newspaper on 24 November 2000, and about a year after that someone started circulating it on the web without authorization or permission from ''The Signal.'' The version that has been circulating on the Internet appears to be a correct copy, other than the incorrect date listing of 25 April 2002 or 2003. The letter to the editor is not on ''The Signal's'' web site because they don't put letters online. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Whether the letter-writer is ''the'' Paul Allen of Microsoft and professional sports team fame is unknown. However, it seems unlikely as ''that'' Mr. Allen resides on Mercer Island, Washington, over one thousand miles north of Santa Clarita, California. | ||
==Conclusion== | ==Conclusion== | ||
| − | Never take faith-promoting stories circulated in chain email messages at face value. Check the sources carefully. | + | Never take faith-promoting stories circulated in chain email messages at face value. Check the sources carefully. |
==Further reading== | ==Further reading== | ||
| − | + | <!-- | |
===FAIR wiki articles=== | ===FAIR wiki articles=== | ||
* | * | ||
Revision as of 16:22, 14 March 2006
This article is a draft. FairMormon editors are currently editing it. We welcome your suggestions on improving the content.
Frequently Latter-day Saints receive email messages with faith-promoting stories that are difficult or impossible to verify. This article includes examples of these "urban legends."
Contents
Sami Hanna on the Book of Mormon
- See main article: Sami Hanna on the Book of Mormon
Frank Graham and LDS hurricane relief
Claim
The following email began circulating in late September 2005, following the destruction caused by Hurricane Katrina:
- I was watching Good Morning America this morning and they spoke with Rev. Frank Graham (son of Billy Graham), who is currently in Houston. He spoke of the desperation and devastation that is the "new" way of life in and around New Orleans, but he also had a different message for the country.
- He told the media that there are many churches in the Houston area, indeed, all around America that have reached out to help the victims, but he said that the members of The LDS church are truly amazing.
- He stated (that)..."those people are truly a charity driven people. In the scriptures, charity is defined as the pure love of Christ." He went on to remark how the members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints have adopted individuals and families in the Astrodome and are helping them to find missing members of their families. They are keeping touch with their designated person or family on a daily basis, making sure the children are enrolled in and can get to school, taking them to Wal-mart and other retailers to purchase clothing and other necessities, and are taking people to job fairs and interviews to assist them in gaining employment. He stated that he has never seen such a love for complete strangers. This has even brought inactive members, according to Graham, "...out of their homes and back to the church because they want to help and they know that the church will be there, organizing and moving to assist those who have nothing, to remember that they truly are something."
- He ended with a personal opinion that anyone in the Houston area who is an evacuee from New Orleans, who says they haven't been "taken care of" or "seen after", has only themselves to blame for refusing the assistance of the amazing LDS population who are volunteering without so much as
asking for anything in return for their efforts."
Response
A Lexis-Nexis check of the Reverend Graham's comments on Good Morning America shows that he made no such comments.
Additionally, FAIR contacted the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association, and received the following email from Jeremy Blume, their media spokesperson, on 28 September 2005:
- I've received this same email from several people. There are many inaccuracies in it. Thank you for your desire to research the truth. We appreciate your offer to help let people know that it isn't accurate.
- It is true that Franklin Graham was on Good Morning America and he praised Christians and followers of Jesus Christ for their response to the hurricane, but he never mentioned any denominations, specific churches, organizations, or groups. Whoever wrote this is adding a lot to his interview.
- Thanks for checking with us. I hope this helps.
FAIR received a second email on 3 October 2005 from Rosemary S. Moore, Administrative Services Correspondent:
- Thank you for contacting us regarding Franklin Graham's appearance on "Good Morning America." We have received correspondence like yours from several people. There are many inaccurate rumors circulating about this particular interview, and we appreciate your desire to know the truth about it.
- It is true that Franklin Graham was on "Good Morning America" on September 16, 2005 and that he praised Christians and followers of Jesus Christ for their response to the hurricane. However, he never mentioned any denominations, specific churches, organizations, or groups.
- We appreciate your checking with us regarding the authenticity of these rumors.
Prophecy of a Catholic Priest
Claim
A persistent rumor claims that Lutus Gratus, a Catholic priest, wrote the following in 1739 in his book Hope of Zion, which was purportedly discovered in the library in Bayd, Switzerland:
- The old, true Gospel and its truths thereat are lost. False doctrine prevail in all churches on the face of the earth today. All we can do is exhort the people to be just, fear God, shun evil, and pray. Prayer and purity may cause an angel to visit a deep distressed soul, but I will tell you—God will have spoken within a hundred years. He will restore the old Church again. I see a little band of people led by a prophet and persecuted, burnt out and murdered. But in a valley that lies on the shore of a great lake, they will build a city and make a beautiful land, have a temple of magnificent splendor and also possess the old priesthood with teachers, deacons, etc. From every nation shall the true believers be gathered by speedy messengers, and then shall the almighty God speak to the disobedient nation, with thunder, lightning and destructions such as man has never known."
Response
This "prophecy" first appeared in LDS periodicals in both English and German in 1893, in a story by a returned missionary named Jacob Spori. One of the first to question the authenticity of the document was Rulon S. Wells of the First Council of Seventy, who unsuccessfully attempted to locate the book and its contents in Basel a few years after the story surfaced. Other leaders and missionaries also were unable to verify the statement.
Elder Wells wrote an article called "A Fraudulent Prophecy Exposed" which was published in the January, 1908 Improvement Era. A detailed historical analysis of the false prophecy was published in BYU Studies in 1985.
- Paul B. Pixton, "'Play it Again, Sam': The Remarkable 'Prophecy' of Samuel Lutz, Alias Christophilus Gratianus, Reconsidered", BYU Studies 25/3 (Summer 1985), pp. 27–46.
Paul Allen's editorial on the "Mormons"
Claim
Paul Allen — co-founder of Microsoft and owner of the Seattle Seahawks and Portland Trail Blazers — wrote a letter praising Mormons that was published in a Santa Clarita, California newspaper.
(One example of this widely-circulated letter can be read in this Usenet post.)
Response
A FAIR volunteer contacted The Signal, Santa Clarita Valley's newspaper, and enquired about this. The general manager of the paper confirmed that a letter to the editor from a Paul Allen was published in the newspaper on 24 November 2000, and about a year after that someone started circulating it on the web without authorization or permission from The Signal. The version that has been circulating on the Internet appears to be a correct copy, other than the incorrect date listing of 25 April 2002 or 2003. The letter to the editor is not on The Signal's web site because they don't put letters online.
Whether the letter-writer is the Paul Allen of Microsoft and professional sports team fame is unknown. However, it seems unlikely as that Mr. Allen resides on Mercer Island, Washington, over one thousand miles north of Santa Clarita, California.
Conclusion
Never take faith-promoting stories circulated in chain email messages at face value. Check the sources carefully.
Further reading
External links
- LDS Hoaxes, Myths, and "Faith Promoting Rumors" at SHIELDS.
- Snopes (general site for urban legends and email hoaxes)