FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Difference between revisions of "Book of Mormon/Tribal affiliations"
m (robot Adding: fr:Book of Mormon/Tribal affiliations) |
GregSmithBot (talk | contribs) m (Robot: Automated text replacement (-Source(s) of the criticism +{{Criticism source label English}}, -Source(s) of the Criticism +{{Criticism source label English}}, -==Criticism== +=={{Criticism label}}==, -==Response== +=={{Response label}}==, -==Qu) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{BoMPortal}} | {{BoMPortal}} | ||
{{draft}} | {{draft}} | ||
| − | ==Criticism== | + | =={{Criticism label}}== |
*Critics claim that the use of tribal affiliation in the Book of Mormon imply a genetic link between the members. | *Critics claim that the use of tribal affiliation in the Book of Mormon imply a genetic link between the members. | ||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
{{CriticalSources}} | {{CriticalSources}} | ||
| − | ==Response== | + | =={{Response label}}== |
{{SeeAlso|Book_of_Mormon/Anachronisms/Demographics|l1=Demographics and population sizes}} | {{SeeAlso|Book_of_Mormon/Anachronisms/Demographics|l1=Demographics and population sizes}} | ||
| Line 23: | Line 23: | ||
:It is true that the name "Nephites" sometimes connotes those who shared culture, religion, and ethnicity or biology.5 But every rule-of-thumb we construct that treats the Nephites as a thoroughly homogeneous unit ends up violated by details in the text. Variety shows through the common label, culturally (e.g., Mosiah 7:15; Alma 8:11–12), religiously (e.g., Mosiah 26:4–5 and 27:1; Alma 8:11), linguistically (e.g., Omni 1:17–18), and biologically (e.g., Alma 3:17, note the statement concerning Nephi's seed "and whomsoever shall be called thy seed"; Alma 55:4). "Nephites" should then be read as the generic name designating the nation (see Alma 9:20) ideally unified in a political structure headed by one direct descendant of Nephi at a time.{{ref|sorenson.1}} | :It is true that the name "Nephites" sometimes connotes those who shared culture, religion, and ethnicity or biology.5 But every rule-of-thumb we construct that treats the Nephites as a thoroughly homogeneous unit ends up violated by details in the text. Variety shows through the common label, culturally (e.g., Mosiah 7:15; Alma 8:11–12), religiously (e.g., Mosiah 26:4–5 and 27:1; Alma 8:11), linguistically (e.g., Omni 1:17–18), and biologically (e.g., Alma 3:17, note the statement concerning Nephi's seed "and whomsoever shall be called thy seed"; Alma 55:4). "Nephites" should then be read as the generic name designating the nation (see Alma 9:20) ideally unified in a political structure headed by one direct descendant of Nephi at a time.{{ref|sorenson.1}} | ||
| − | ==Conclusion== | + | =={{Conclusion label}}== |
The Book of Mormon text makes it clear that tribal designation has a political role. Individuals switch tribal designation as their religious and political loyalties shift. The critics view of them as strictly genetic categories cannot be maintained beyond the first few years of settlement. | The Book of Mormon text makes it clear that tribal designation has a political role. Individuals switch tribal designation as their religious and political loyalties shift. The critics view of them as strictly genetic categories cannot be maintained beyond the first few years of settlement. | ||
| − | ==Endnotes== | + | =={{Endnotes label}}== |
#{{note|sorenson.1}} {{JBMS-1-1-2}} | #{{note|sorenson.1}} {{JBMS-1-1-2}} | ||
| − | ==Further reading== | + | =={{Further reading label}}== |
| − | ===FAIR wiki articles=== | + | ==={{FAIR wiki articles label}}=== |
{{BoMGeographyWiki}} | {{BoMGeographyWiki}} | ||
| − | ===FAIR web site=== | + | ==={{FAIR web site label}}=== |
*{{tg|url=http://www.fairlds.org/apol/ai113.html|topic=New World Context of Book of Mormon}} | *{{tg|url=http://www.fairlds.org/apol/ai113.html|topic=New World Context of Book of Mormon}} | ||
*Matthew Roper, "Book of Mormon Peoples and Pre-columbian Populations" {{fairlink|url=http://www.fairlds.org/pubs/conf/2003RopM.html}} | *Matthew Roper, "Book of Mormon Peoples and Pre-columbian Populations" {{fairlink|url=http://www.fairlds.org/pubs/conf/2003RopM.html}} | ||
*Steven J. Danderson, "Adding Up the Book of Mormon Peoples," {{fairlink|url=http://www.fairlds.org/Book_of_Mormon/Adding_Up_the_Book_of_Mormon_Peoples.html}} | *Steven J. Danderson, "Adding Up the Book of Mormon Peoples," {{fairlink|url=http://www.fairlds.org/Book_of_Mormon/Adding_Up_the_Book_of_Mormon_Peoples.html}} | ||
| − | ===External links=== | + | ==={{External links label}}=== |
*{{FR-6-1-9}} | *{{FR-6-1-9}} | ||
*{{JBMS-1-1-2}} | *{{JBMS-1-1-2}} | ||
| − | ===Printed material=== | + | ==={{Printed material label}}=== |
*{{revisited1|author=James E. Smith|article=How Many Nephites? The Book of Mormon at the Bar of Demography|start=Chapter 10}} | *{{revisited1|author=James E. Smith|article=How Many Nephites? The Book of Mormon at the Bar of Demography|start=Chapter 10}} | ||
*{{Aas1|start=1}} | *{{Aas1|start=1}} | ||
Revision as of 02:06, 4 May 2010
| Answers portal |
| Book of Mormon |
|
 RESOURCES
|
|---|
|
General information: Book of Mormon & Bible: Criticisms: |
 PERSPECTIVES
|
 MEDIA
|
| OTHER PORTALS
|
This article is a draft. FairMormon editors are currently editing it. We welcome your suggestions on improving the content.
Contents
Questions
==
- Critics claim that the use of tribal affiliation in the Book of Mormon imply a genetic link between the members.
To see citations to the critical sources for these claims, click here
==Detailed Analysis
==
Contrary to the claims of the critics, the Book of Mormon is clear that tribal designation is a political, not genetic matter.
On author noted:
- An analysis of the terminology applied to peoples in the Book of Mormon could reveal useful information on this subject. This is not the place to do that fully, but the approach can be sketched and some of the results anticipated. References to the key people of the record vary: (1) "Nephite(s)" or "the Nephites" occurs 339 times; (2) "people of the Nephites," 18 times; (3) "people of Nephi," 4 times; (4) "children of Nephi," twice, and (5) "descendants of Nephi," twice. Usage of the second and third expressions gives us something to ponder about the composition of the people referred to.
- The meaning of the first expression is made clear early by Jacob when he says, "those who are friendly to Nephi I shall call Nephites." Then he continues the definition in an interesting way: ". . . or the people of Nephi, according to the reigns of the kings" (Jacob 1:14). A few lines earlier Jacob had reported that when Nephi anticipated his own death, he had designated "a [successor] king and a ruler over his people . . . according to the reigns of the kings. . . . And whoso should reign in his stead were called by the people, second Nephi, third Nephi, and so forth, according to the reigns of the kings; and thus they were called by the people, let them be of whatever [personal] name they would" (Jacob 1:9, 11). Jacob here makes clear that his definition of "Nephites, or the people of Nephi" hinges on political allegiance to a king, a king who always bore the title "Nephi." This definition does not depend at all on whether "Nephites" were or were not literal descendants from Nephi, nor whether they had Sam, Jacob, Joseph, or Zoram, the founding fathers of the group, among their ancestors. In fact Jacob's terminology may refer to the original father Nephi only indirectly. What he says in verse 11, where the term "Nephites" is first used, is that those classified under that term were simply all who were ruled by the existing monarch, the current "Nephi." No reason is evident to me to believe that in the 338 usages after Jacob begins the practice that "Nephite(s)" means anything else. It is essentially a sociopolitical, not an ethnic or linguistic, label.
- Cases where the text reports that political allegiance changed are consistent with this notion. Thus the children who had been fathered, then abandoned, by the renegade priests of Noah chose to "be numbered among those who were called Nephites" (Mosiah 25:12). That is, when they came under the sovereignty of the current head of the Nephite government, they both gave their allegiance to him and changed their group label to "Nephites." In a parallel case earlier, "all the people of Zarahemla were numbered with the Nephites, and this because the kingdom had been conferred upon none but those who were descendants of Nephi" (Mosiah 25:13). Conversely, when Amlici and his followers rebelled against Nephite rule and "did consecrate Amlici to be their king," they took a unique group name to mark the political rebellion, "being called Amlicites" (Alma 2:9). Meanwhile "the remainder"—those loyal to Alma, the continuing official ruler—"were [still] called Nephites" (Mosiah 25:11). Again, when the Zoramites transferred allegiance from the Nephite government to the Lamanite side, they "became Lamanites" (Alma 43:4, 6). We see, then, that the Nephites constituted those governed by the ruling "Nephi," who was always a direct descendant of the original Nephi. But the label does not of itself convey information about the ethnic, linguistic, or physical characteristics or origin of those called Nephites.
- It is true that the name "Nephites" sometimes connotes those who shared culture, religion, and ethnicity or biology.5 But every rule-of-thumb we construct that treats the Nephites as a thoroughly homogeneous unit ends up violated by details in the text. Variety shows through the common label, culturally (e.g., Mosiah 7:15; Alma 8:11–12), religiously (e.g., Mosiah 26:4–5 and 27:1; Alma 8:11), linguistically (e.g., Omni 1:17–18), and biologically (e.g., Alma 3:17, note the statement concerning Nephi's seed "and whomsoever shall be called thy seed"; Alma 55:4). "Nephites" should then be read as the generic name designating the nation (see Alma 9:20) ideally unified in a political structure headed by one direct descendant of Nephi at a time.[1]
Answer
==
The Book of Mormon text makes it clear that tribal designation has a political role. Individuals switch tribal designation as their religious and political loyalties shift. The critics view of them as strictly genetic categories cannot be maintained beyond the first few years of settlement. == Notes ==
- [note] John L. Sorenson, "When Lehi's Party Arrived in the Land Did They Find Others There?," Journal of Book of Mormon Studies 1/1 (1992). [1–34] link
Further reading
FairMormon Answers articles
FairMormon web site
- FairMormon Topical Guide: New World Context of Book of Mormon FairMormon link
- Matthew Roper, "Book of Mormon Peoples and Pre-columbian Populations" FAIR link
- Steven J. Danderson, "Adding Up the Book of Mormon Peoples," FAIR link
External links
- James E. Smith, "Nephi's Descendants? Historical Demography and the Book of Mormon (Review of Multiply Exceedingly: Book of Mormon Population Sizes by John C. Kunich)," FARMS Review of Books 6/1 (1994): 255–296. off-site
- John L. Sorenson, "When Lehi's Party Arrived in the Land Did They Find Others There?," Journal of Book of Mormon Studies 1/1 (1992). [1–34] link
Printed material
- James E. Smith, "How Many Nephites? The Book of Mormon at the Bar of Demography," in Book of Mormon Authorship Revisited: The Evidence for Ancient Origins, edited by Noel B. Reynolds, (Provo, Utah : Foundation for Ancient Research and Mormon Studies, 1997), Chapter 10. ISBN 093489325X ISBN 0934893187 ISBN 0884944697. off-site GL direct link
- John L. Sorenson, An Ancient American Setting for the Book of Mormon (Salt Lake City, Utah : Deseret Book Co. ; Provo, Utah : Foundation for Ancient Research and Mormon Studies, 1996 [1985]), 1.
- John L. Sorenson, Mormon's Map (Provo, Utah: FARMS, 2000), 111. ISBN 0934893489.